model-writtenrun 8018 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- John Naylor reported duplicate symbols for heap_tableam_handler() and initially worried that removing either might break external code; Tom Lane recommended removing the nonstandard HEAP_TABLE_AM_HANDLER_OID on the development branch without backpatching #1 #2.
- John Naylor posted a patch replacing the nonstandard symbol and rejecting future custom pg_proc symbols, then added an explanatory comment; Michael Paquier supported removal after finding no external uses #3 #4 #5.
- Tom Lane committed the revised pg_proc patch with an error-message wording change as 36b9312143, then proposed applying the same prohibition to pg_type #6.
- John Naylor supported preventing further copied exceptions, while Andres Freund warned that client applications use type OID macros and supplied evidence of external CASHOID and LSNOID references #7 #8 #10.
- Tom Lane proposed preserving CASHOID and LSNOID as handwritten aliases in pg_type.h while renaming the remaining exceptions, rejecting a new backward_compat_oid_symbol attribute as unnecessary generator complexity; Andres Freund accepted the alias approach and confirmed that custom pg_type symbols would be rejected #9 #11 #12 #14.
- John Naylor posted the separate pg_type patch implementing the prohibition, standard names, and two compatibility aliases #15.
- Tom Lane committed that patch as f90149e628 with additional LSNOID renames and cosmetic adjustments; the commit left other legacy aliases out but allowed reconsideration if users objected, and his final message confirmed that both changes had landed #16.