model-writtenrun 7795 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Justin Pryzby proposed removing pg_standby and pg_archivecleanup for PostgreSQL 14 because he considered them obsolete and confusing alongside modern streaming replication #1.
- Michael Banck explained that pg_archivecleanup remained useful for expiring archived WAL associated with old backups #2, leading Justin to withdraw its removal #3; Robert Haas and Michael Paquier subsequently confirmed its continuing usefulness #5 #6.
- Heikki Linnakangas revisited earlier objections to retiring pg_standby and asked whether recovery-target settings now covered its fast-failover functionality, supporting removal unless an essential capability remained missing #4.
- Peter Eisentraut noticed that removing pg_standby left an empty documentation section #7, so Justin revised that section and included a separate fix for two missing words #8.
- Peter committed the typo patch from #8 unchanged as 2fbd786c34, while leaving the retirement decision open #9.
- After a two-month gap, Thomas Munro revived Justin's removal patch because waiting restore commands conflicted with proposed recovery prefetching, repaired a dangling documentation reference, and added his own patch deleting the instructions for implementing such commands #10.
- Michael Paquier found two further pg_standby references and questioned whether WAL recycling logic could be simplified #11; Thomas removed the references but retained the regular-file check as useful protection #12.
- Fujii Masao supported retirement but requested consideration of a deprecation period #13; Michael argued that retaining the tool would obstruct development #14, and Thomas noted that users could continue using the standalone PostgreSQL 13 executable #15.
- Thomas committed both patches from #12 with unchanged diffs: Justin's pg_standby removal as 514b411a2b and Thomas's documentation removal as 5c6d184213; his final announcement closed the remaining work, with pg_archivecleanup retained #16.