model-writtenrun 6326 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Alexander Lakhin opened the thread with a reproducer for Windows directory-listing failures on files pending deletion and proposed retrying ERROR_ACCESS_DENIED inside _pgstat64(), while asking how to ensure callers used the replacement stat() implementation #1.
- Justin Pryzby spotted that the retry counter did not limit the loop, and Alexander added the missing bound #2 #3.
- Alexander explored exposing file metadata already obtained by Windows directory enumeration, while Juan José SantamarÃa Flecha suggested an attribute-based fallback and argued that retries belonged in callers; these alternatives were not incorporated into the submitted fix #4 #5.
- Tom Lane explained that the existing deletion checks were unreachable when opening a delete-pending file failed, recommended removing them, and supported using microsoft_native_stat() in open.c #6.
- Tom's buildfarm investigation raised the possibility that a one-second timeout was insufficient, while Alexander traced the older-branch statistics-file failures to Cygwin, which did not use the Windows open() wrappers; neither issue was resolved by these patches #7 #9 #10.
- After several months, Alexander revived the work with fresh buildfarm failures and a separate open.c patch using microsoft_native_stat(); Michael Paquier later requested the complete fix for testing #11 #12 #14.
- Alexander extended the stat() patch to remove the ineffective deletion-query machinery, and Michael confirmed the reproducer and concurrent pgbench testing, combined the open.c change, and removed the unnecessary genfile.c include with Alexander's agreement #15 #16 #17.
- Michael committed the combined patch from #16 as 54fb8c7ddf, changing only a stale comment and formatting; his follow-up left a possible timeout increase open pending buildfarm evidence #18.
- The fairywren MinGW build failed immediately, and Michael reverted the change in 2c9b46c090 because microsoft_native_stat() was unavailable there and a safe replacement needed further study #19 #20.
- Alexander supplied a portability revision that disabled stat() overriding inside the implementation files and reported successful compilation with MSVC, MinGW32, and MinGW64; testing also exposed an unhandled ERROR_SHARING_VIOLATION case, which he asked whether to address separately #24.
- By December, Michael still lacked the MinGW testing infrastructure needed to proceed, and Alexander proposed withdrawing the patch in favor of Thomas Munro's direct STATUS_DELETE_PENDING approach; the thread ends with the original landing reverted and no second landing of the revised patch #26 #27.