model-writtenrun 7702 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Thomas Munro opened the thread with #1, implementing Andres Freund's suggestion to use ProcSignalBarrier to make backends close file descriptors before retrying DROP TABLESPACE on Windows; he considered targeted invalidation processing unsafe at arbitrary interrupt checks and also proposed replacing barrier polling with condition variables.
- After correcting the patch split in #2, Thomas incorporated Andres Freund's request for storage-manager callback dispatch from #3 into #4.
- Andres Freund questioned the cost of forcing a checkpoint in #3, and Thomas explored separate tombstone tracking and crash-recovery requirements in #4 and #5, leaving checkpoint avoidance outside the immediate barrier fix.
- In #6, Thomas fixed a missing condition-variable broadcast during process cleanup and separated interrupt-safe condition-variable waiting into its own prerequisite patch.
- The two prerequisites from #6 landed unchanged as 814f1d8bc3 and f5a5773a9d; Thomas posted the remaining tablespace patch in #7 and argued that closing all descriptors was a reasonable initial compromise for a rare Windows operation.
- Daniel Gustafsson tested the remaining patch on Linux and macOS and requested tablespace redo coverage, clearer testing comments, and relocation of the barrier handler into smgr.c in #8; Thomas implemented those changes in #9, and Daniel reported further successful testing in #11.
- Thomas expanded the patch in #12 to cover DROP DATABASE, ALTER DATABASE SET TABLESPACE, and database redo after Andres identified the analogous Windows failure, which Andres also documented in #13.
- Thomas's exploratory checkpoint-avoidance work continued with a WAL-level-dependent tombstone proposal in #10 and discussion of unlogged tables in #14, before he moved that subtopic out of this thread in #15.
- Daniel examined the consequences of releasing TablespaceCreateLock while waiting for the barrier and tested concurrent tablespace creation in #16; Thomas reasoned in #17 that the resulting races already existed and that removing empty directories before an interrupted wait was harmless.
- The remaining patch encountered a cfbot timeout attributed to an oversight in the development branch in #18; when Robert Haas revisited it in #19, that blocker was fixed, and he requested an explicit testing configuration symbol instead of tying behavior to assertions.
- Thomas adopted Robert's configuration change and committed the final patch from #12 as 4eb2176318, with Windows behavior preserved and Unix testing enabled explicitly through USE_BARRIER_SMGRRELEASE.
- In the final message #20, Thomas confirmed the fix was pushed and agreed to keep it on the development branch rather than backpatch the first use of the barrier machinery; all three components had landed, while checkpoint avoidance and further uses of the mechanism continued separately.