model-writtenrun 7665 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Tom Lane opened the thread with #1, proposing to reject '=' and '-' in custom GUC names because catalog storage and command-line parsing mishandled them, while centralizing lookup errors in find_option() and recommending no backpatch.
- Noah Misch advocated identifier-style restrictions to exclude other troublesome characters in #2, and Robert Haas reinforced that proposal with examples of inconsistent punctuation handling in #5; Darafei Praliaskouski supported the initial restriction in #4.
- Andrew Dunstan questioned whether identifier-only names were too restrictive and suggested allowing '-' or ':' in #6, while acknowledging that few users would likely be burdened.
- Tom Lane returned with #8, explaining that '-' remained incompatible with command-line parsing and choosing exactly two identifier components for simplicity; the revised patch replaced the blacklist with a validator and changed tests to reject names containing spaces.
- Tom Lane committed #8 unchanged apart from rebasing as 3db826bd55, then confirmed in #9 that the more restrictive version had landed after no further comments; the change was deliberately not backpatched.