model-writtenrun 7725 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Tom Lane proposed explicit RAINBOW arcs and match-all NFA recognition in #1, reducing compilation overhead and replacing repeated scans of unconstrained subexpressions with length checks; he chose to expose RAINBOW through the regex export API and adapt pg_trgm.
- Joel Jacobson tested real website regexes and found 23 capture discrepancies in #2; Tom corrected boundary-pseudocolor handling in #4, and Joel's retest in #5 found matching results plus one formerly oversized regex that now compiled.
- Tom expanded the series in #7 to remove empty concatenation nodes and represent alternation with one parent and sibling-linked children, avoiding redundant NFA compilation; Joel verified all four patches in #8.
- Tom extracted the existing compact() fix and lookaround tests, together with assertion and debugging improvements, into 4e703d6719, which became the base identified in #9.
- The five-patch revision in #9 added capture annotations directly to matching nodes while retaining wrapper nodes for nested equivalent captures such as ((x)); it also separated capture, backreference, and lookaround fields.
- Joel validated the five-patch submission against more than three million cases in #10 and demonstrated a dramatic match-all speedup in #11, while Tom clarified the benchmark interpretation in #12.
- Examining corpus failures in #13, Tom identified complemented character-class escapes as a worthwhile compatibility improvement, considered larger repetition limits, and retained stricter treatment of several other JavaScript constructs.
- Joel proposed character-range and multi-character transition optimizations in #14; Tom explained in #16 that existing colors already implement the first idea and that simultaneous NFA states complicate the second.
- Joel explained the newline-inclusive purpose of [\w\W] in #18 and compared PostgreSQL, JavaScript, and Perl behavior in #20, prompting discussion of newline semantics.
- The RAINBOW and match-all members of #9 landed unchanged as 08c0d6ad65 and 824bf71902.
- The remaining members of #9 landed as cebc1d34e5, 5810430894, and ea1268f630, with only a small debug-output addition and flag documentation beyond the submitted patches.
- Chapman Flack proposed locally scoped regex flags in #21, and Tom supported investigating the feature in #22, but no implementation was submitted here.
- Andres Freund reported a GCC array-bounds warning in #23; after discussing compiler assumptions and avoiding a PostgreSQL-specific unreachable primitive, Tom chose an always-on depth check in #29 and committed 3db05e76f9.
- Tom proposed separate compact-NFA lists for lookaround arcs and a one-entry constraint cache in #31, substantially improving one Tcl-derived example without addressing its quadratic behavior.
- Broader testing found little benefit and occasional regressions from that lookaround patch, so Tom shelved it in #32 and instead submitted smaller initial per-state arc allocations with geometrically growing batches.
- The complemented-character-class work motivated here was submitted in thread #43728 and landed as 2a0af7fe46; Joel later observed its expected compatibility effects in #35.
- Tom replaced per-state arc storage with NFA-wide pools and batched states in #33, dramatically reducing worst-case memory use; in #34 he traced the old bloat to stranded per-state capacity and proposed relinking moved arcs directly.
- Joel successfully tested the pooled allocator in #35, and Tom landed it as 0fc1af174c with additional allocation cursors and direct arc relinking, then acknowledged the testing in #36.
- Tom completed an unattached follow-up in 4604f83fdf, suppressing iteration and concatenation nodes needed only because of conflicting greediness.
- Joel's final comparison in #37 found no unexpected match-position differences and an old timeout now running quickly, followed by Noah Misch's acknowledgement in #38; the main optimizations had landed, while the lookaround-list patch remained shelved and local flags remained an exploratory idea.