model-writtenrun 5583 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
Feb - Mar 2021 · 6 entries
- Thomas Munro opened the thread with a three-patch proposal to consolidate PostgreSQL's duplicated quicksort implementations into a C template and replace the Perl tuple-sort generator, leaving additional specializations for follow-up work #1.
- Andres Freund demonstrated the potential for new consumers by reporting that a specialized checkpointer sort reduced sorting time for a largely dirty 64 GB buffer pool from about 1.4 seconds to 0.6 seconds #2.
- Daniel Gustafsson tested a generated string sorter, reported passing tests, and supported the template approach; Thomas incorporated formatting feedback but considered an extra documentation pointer in the tiny qsort wrapper redundant #3 #4.
- The original series landed as the lightly polished template introduction 0a1f1d3cac, the unchanged generic-sort conversion f374f4d664, and the unchanged tuple-sort conversion 8eda3eba30, all sourced from #1.
- Thomas then posted the checkpointer specialization, Andres approved it, and its bufmgr.c changes landed unchanged #4 #5 1b88b8908e.
- Andres's request for similar binary-search support led Thomas to propose search and deduplication templates, wider comparator return types, shared scalar and ItemPointer routines, and several local specializations whose executable-size cost still needed justification #5 #6 #7.
Jun - Aug 2021 · 6 entries
- The expanded series returned in June with formatting fixes, and Zhihong Yu identified documentation, comparator-type naming and midpoint-overflow issues; Thomas accepted those corrections but abandoned manually maintained typedef-list additions after Tom Lane explained why generated lists would overwrite them #10 #8 #11 #12 #14 #15 #19.
- John Naylor reviewed the expanded series and questioned its organization and performance assumptions, while Thomas explained that reusable typed routines offered notation and deduplication benefits even where cache misses hid speedups #18 #19.
- Thomas supplied a benchmark module, and John added an ItemPointer comparator that compared its 16-bit components directly instead of assembling wider integers; both reported substantial improvements, while the wider arithmetic approach looked unpromising #21 #23 #24.
- Thomas opened a separate tuple-sort acceleration experiment using three common Datum comparator representations, and John's benchmarks and identical resend supported pursuing it #26 #30.
- Peter Geoghegan requested broader abbreviated-key coverage, so Thomas added UUID, MAC address, network and GiST consumers and renamed the misleading binary comparator to unsigned, while leaving additional specialization dimensions as future research #31 #34 #35.
- With Thomas's agreement, John committed the tuple-key specialization patch from #34 without code changes, recording Peter's review and his own performance testing #46 #47 6974924347.
Jan - Feb 2022 · 3 entries
- After a several-month gap, John resumed review and testing, reporting useful tuple-sort gains but little support for several branchless-comparison experiments, and distinguishing promising changes from those still needing workload evidence #38 #39 #42.
- John separately committed Thomas's missing ST_CHECK_FOR_INTERRUPTS undefinition from the expanded tarball series, preventing the template parameter from leaking into later inclusions #42 #43 0526f2f4c3.
- John's threshold experiments across Intel and Power hardware supported raising the insertion-sort cutoff toward 20, but regression-output changes delayed that work; the remaining refactoring and experimental specializations were also deferred toward the next development cycle #43 #44 #45.
Mar - May 2022 · 9 entries
- UBsan and Valgrind immediately exposed uninitialized SortTuple fields during expression-based CLUSTER operations; Justin Pryzby's reproducer and Andres Freund's analysis helped establish that those sorts must bypass the datum1-based specializations #49 #50 #53 #56.
- Thomas first proposed disabling the optimized paths, then adopted explicit haveDatum1 initialization and Andres's consolidated guard; the revised patch landed with a comment adjustment and equivalent guard cleanup in comparetup_cluster() #57 #58 #59 #60 cc58eecc5d.
- John posted a standalone insertion-threshold patch with updated regression expectations after deciding that adding sort keys to the tests would be intrusive and insufficient, and requested review before committing it #48 #62.
- David Rowley reported a substantial regression for single-key sorts with many duplicate integers, prompting Thomas to propose separate variants that avoid unnecessary tie-breaking calls #63 #65.
- David replaced the additional generated variants with a flag check inside the existing comparators, and benchmarks from both David and John showed that this narrower fix restored performance while leaving broader specialization choices for future work #69 #70 #71 #72.
- John questioned the new flag's initialization and overlap with onlyKey, leading David to reuse onlyKey instead; John retested and approved that smaller patch, which David committed with equivalent separated checks and revised comments #73 #74 #75 #78 99c754129d.
- David's additional two-key benchmark found no regression requiring an immediate fix, and Thomas agreed with postponing further specialization choices rather than expanding generated code during the bug-fix phase #78 #80.
- Justin later questioned the new DEBUG1 chatter, Peter agreed it was too noisy, and Tom Lane supported removal because the messages lacked useful context; John removed all five dispatch messages directly from that discussion #81 #82 #83 #84 6e647ef0e7.
- At the final message, the template, checkpointer specialization, tuple-key acceleration, correctness and performance fixes, and debug cleanup had landed, while the broader sort/search experiments and insertion-threshold proposal remained deferred or awaiting review in this thread #45 #62 #80 #85.