model-writtenrun 5964 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Bharath Rupireddy proposed clearer publication errors for foreign, temporary and unlogged tables, with regression coverage, because the existing foreign-table error misleadingly said the object was not a table #1.
- Jeevan Ladhe tested the initial patch successfully and questioned redundant error details #2, while Euler Taveira recommended identifying the rejected table type and explaining that it cannot join a publication #4; Bharath adopted that wording in #5.
- After rebases, Euler identified a redundant permanence check and supplied clearer commit wording #8, both of which Bharath incorporated in #9.
- Vignesh proposed extending the diagnostics to indexes and composite types through OpenTableList() and supplied a supplemental patch #10 #12, but Bharath declined it because the existing errors already made those unsupported object types clear and resent the original patch #13.
- Following a July rebase #14, Bharath adapted the patch to the upstream relkind improvements in 81d5995b4b, removing redundant foreign-table handling and retaining separate temporary/unlogged diagnostics with tests #15.
- The work resumed in November with a refreshed patch #17, and Daniel Gustafsson judged its more specific diagnostics ready to commit #18.
- Euler then proposed centralizing persistence-specific diagnostics in errdetail_relkind_not_supported(), supplying a broader patch that updated callers throughout the backend and extensions #19.
- Bharath expanded that design to recognize system tables and provide two helper interfaces #20; after Euler questioned the wrapper and redundant OID argument #21, Bharath retained two interfaces but simplified their names and parameters #23.
- Peter Eisentraut objected that the generalized helper could describe an incidental property rather than the actual reason a relation was rejected #24, and Daniel favored the earlier small patch #25, leading Bharath to restore it unchanged #26.
- Peter requested explicit relpersistence comparisons for clarity #27, Daniel agreed #28, and Bharath supplied the final revision with that adjustment #29.
- Daniel committed #29 as aa12781b0d with only commit-description edits and announced completion in the last message #30; the shared-helper experiment and index/composite-type extension were left out.