model-writtenrun 6340 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- David Christensen proposed extending pg_size_pretty(numeric) through yottabytes with a lookup array, documentation and tests in #1, then supplied a dependent pg_size_bytes expansion that also changed its return type to numeric in #3.
- Asif Rehman found declaration-order and variable-length-array compilation failures in #4, and Christensen corrected those issues while rebasing and resubmitting both patches in #5.
- Shinya Kato questioned the need for yottabytes in #6, while David Rowley argued that unfamiliar units might reduce readability and break consumers without a practical requirement in #9.
- Isaac Morland supported including standard prefixes but proposed simplifying output formatting and questioned binary quantities using SI labels in #10; Christensen accepted the formatting suggestion while warning that changing established unit meanings would break compatibility in #11.
- Christensen explained that large synthetic workloads motivated the change in #12, and Rowley proposed separating cleanup from unit expansion in #13, leading to the two-part submission in #16.
- Rowley replaced Christensen's separate lookup arrays with one table shared by both pg_size_pretty overloads and pg_size_bytes in #17, then refined its iteration and rounding bookkeeping in #18.
- Dean Rasheed warned that repeated rounding was misleading and potentially unsafe in #19 and demonstrated error accumulation in #21; Christensen reported successful testing in #22, and Tom Lane suggested const storage and a different field name in #23.
- Rowley incorporated that feedback in #25, restoring an explicit rounding flag and deriving transitions from adjacent unit sizes.
- While testing unit boundaries, Rasheed discovered that negative bigint inputs could choose different units or rounded values from equivalent numeric inputs in #27, tracing the discrepancy to signed bit shifts and rounding behavior.
- Christensen submitted separate numeric-return and PB/EB expansion patches in #28, but Lane objected to breaking existing views and recommended stopping at PB in #29; Christensen acknowledged those concerns in #30.
- Rowley separated the pre-existing rounding bug from the refactor and supplied a backpatchable fix in #32; Rasheed extended it with clearer numeric division terminology and boundary tests in #33.
- Rowley agreed to preserve the bigint return type and limit new units to PB in #34, and reported testing billions of positive and negative values against both overloads without discrepancies in #35.
- The rounding fix from #33 landed unchanged apart from whitespace as 55fe609387, with backports through PostgreSQL 9.6.
- The shared-table refactor from #25 landed as 56ff8b2991, adapted to preserve the newly corrected division and rounding behavior.
- The PB-only portion of #28 landed with revised tests as ca2e4472ba; Rowley's closing message #37 confirmed completion of the reduced scope, leaving the numeric return type and larger units out because of compatibility, readability and bigint-range concerns.