model-writtenrun 6168 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Smith proposed alphabetizing CREATE SUBSCRIPTION's confusing WITH-option list without changing its descriptions #1, and Euler Taveira said the patch looked good #2.
- Amit Kapila proposed grouping related options instead #3; Peter preferred a simple alphabetical list because there were few options #4, while Amit anticipated growth, including a two-phase-commit option #5.
- After several months, Peter rebased the alphabetical reorder onto the updated documentation #6.
- Tom Lane supported separating creation-time options from later replication behavior and also requested grammar and markup cleanup #7; Amit supplied the concrete two-group classification and clarified that the replication group did not simply correspond to ALTER SUBSCRIPTION's options #8.
- Peter adopted that classification, retaining alphabetical order within each group, and split the work into grouping and rewording patches #9; Amit then polished the grouping patch and reposted both, leaving the grammatical changes for Tom to assess #10.
- Amit committed the grouping patch from #10 unchanged as fee1040fe3, while explicitly leaving the rewording patch pending and considering closure of the CommitFest entry #11.
- Tom subsequently revised the second patch from #10, expanded the clarifications and copy-editing to both CREATE and ALTER SUBSCRIPTION, and committed the result as 1882d6cca1, reporting completion in #12.
- Amit acknowledged Tom's completion #13, leaving both parts landed and no outstanding work stated in the thread.