model-writtenrun 6328 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
Apr - May 2021 · 7 entries
- Vignesh C proposed identifying duplicate options with option-specific hints after encountering unhelpful errors while reviewing logical replication work, and attached the initial implementation in #1.
- Bharath Rupireddy and Dilip Kumar explained that the additional information belonged in DETAIL rather than HINT, and Vignesh changed the messages and punctuation in #4 following #2 and #3.
- Alvaro Herrera advocated one parameterized primary message plus cursor positions, while recommending that more complicated conflicting-option cases remain separate; Vignesh implemented the broader duplicate-option wording in #13 after #7 and #9, and Bharath moved a discovered collation-validation issue to another thread in #12.
- Bharath supplied a compute_common_attribute() supplement in #15 and revised it alongside unchanged copies of the main patch in #17 and #21, but Dilip and Peter Smith questioned the altered control flow in #20 and #22; Bharath withdrew the goto replacement in favor of a one-line message change in #24, which Vignesh incorporated in #26.
- Bharath proposed consolidating repeated error blocks in #28, while Alvaro argued that command APIs could accept ParseState to improve cursor positioning in #29 and #31; Vignesh combined per-function error labels with broader ParseState propagation in #34.
- Bharath and Dilip endorsed the consolidated version in #36 and #37, and Zhijie Hou's review of unnecessary compiler-quiet comments in #40 and #44 led to the cleanup in #45.
- Alvaro proposed replacing the repeated error labels with one shared reporting function in #46, which Vignesh implemented in #48 and refined with a noreturn annotation and a single conditional-position error report in #51 following #50.
Jun - Jul 2021 · 7 entries
- After the May work, Vignesh resumed with rebases in #52 and #53, and Daniel Gustafsson's review in #54 led to removing obsolete variable-declaration movements in #55.
- Dean Rasheed found that some reported option names were internal grammar representations and that some supposed duplicates were actually conflicting options in #56 and #61; he also explained why an error-only reporting function should not be forced inline in #60.
- Vignesh responded with two non-inline reporting functions for duplicate and redundant options in #63, while leaving the walsender cases unchanged.
- Dean showed that the revised wording still misclassified alternative syntaxes and lacked sufficient regression coverage, then posted #64 with the original primary error preserved, one shared errorConflictingDefElem() function, and expanded cursor positioning.
- Vignesh accepted Dean's incremental approach and reported that the revised patch applied cleanly and passed tests in #65.
- Dean committed a slightly reduced version of #64 as 2bfb50b3df, omitting helper conversions where no ParseState was available and simplifying the helper's null handling; his announcement in #66 explained that those omitted sites would benefit more from separately reviewed error details.
- Vignesh initially kept the commitfest entry waiting for a follow-up patch in #67, then marked it committed in #68 and deferred the remaining error-detail improvements until after his other projects.