model-writtenrun 7463 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund opened the thread by asking why dummy-probe generation needed both Perl and sed implementations; Tom Lane explained that non-Windows tarball builds must not require Perl and that the sed script also serves as the Perl generator's source #1 #2.
- Dagfinn Ilmari Mannsåker explained that s2p remained available separately on CPAN, and Andrew Dunstan proposed documenting the rationale, authoritative sed source, and regeneration procedure #4 #5.
- Andrew supplied a README and explicit regeneration recipe in #6, which landed unchanged as 8292c0675a; Tom's README approval and Andres's thanks did not provide substantive pre-commit review evidence under the requested criteria #7 #8.
- After that landing, Peter Eisentraut reported regeneration differences, while Dagfinn and Andrew reported identical output in their tests; Tom then demonstrated that deleting the existing Perl script lost its header and first code line because the recipe depended on the previous output #11 #12 #13 #14.
- Andrew addressed that dependency with a static prolog and preserved the first code line from s2p in #15; Tom accepted the approach but identified a likely missing source-directory prefix for VPATH builds #16.
- Andrew initially questioned the need for VPATH support, but Andres explained that developers regenerate the Windows script on other platforms, tested the recipe, and supplied source-path corrections; Andrew then proposed inline recipes that forced output into the source tree #17 #18 #19 #20 #21 #22.
- Alvaro Herrera supplied a revised patch with conditional VPATH targeting and a pipeline after finding problems with the proposed rules, while Tom argued for ordinary Makefile target handling rather than forcing source-tree output #23 #24.
- At the thread's final messages, Andrew briefly said he would use Alvaro's suggestion, then recognized that it also forced source-tree output and said he would resolve the remaining choice #25 #26.
- The subsequent commit 0bf62931ca resolved that choice by retaining Andrew's static-prolog recipe from #15, correcting input paths for VPATH builds, and documenting build-tree output; Alvaro's conditional target and pipeline from #23 were left out.