model-writtenrun 5932 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Fabien COELHO proposed replacing rand48 with a small-state xoroshiro128** generator and an implementation-independent API in #1, explaining in #3 that full-width output, statistical quality and maintainability justified a small performance cost.
- Andrey Borodin raised MT19937 as a widely used alternative in #4, but Fabien rejected its large state and initialization overhead for PostgreSQL's numerous temporary and per-client generators in #6.
- Aleksander Alekseev found missing test_integerset conversions and supplied an updated patch in #5, then reported successful installcheck-world and feature checks in #9.
- Tom Lane identified missing Windows build integration in #11 and requested moving the implementation from src/port to src/common in #13, while Dean Rasheed objected to biased modulo reduction and requested a bounded-generator API in #14; Fabien combined those changes in #19.
- Yura Sokolov reviewed typedef conventions and proposed preserving array-based state in #21; Tom and Fabien favored a struct-based interface in #22 and #23, while the PostgreSQL integer typedef correction was adopted in #24.
- Dean demonstrated that the splitmix retry scheme still biased bounded output in #25 and #27, prompting Fabien to advance the main generator on retries in #28 and abandon the guarantee of exactly one state advance per API call.
- Yura proposed faster specialized range-generation paths in #31 and #35, but Dean and Fabien favored a single simple rejection method over additional complexity in #36 and #40.
- Dean's testing exposed a full-width mask shift bug in #36; Fabien switched to high-bit extraction in #37 and then adopted inclusive minimum and maximum bounds in #39, allowing the API to represent every uint64 range.
- After the summer gap and a CI failure report in #41, Fabien expanded the conversion to remaining random() users, introduced a process-wide PRNG state, and repaired missed backend and extension callers across #42, #43, #44 and #45.
- Tom objected that removing startup srandom() calls would make external-library and extension random() sequences predictable in #46, so Fabien restored that seeding and converted auto_explain's remaining caller in #47.
- Fabien isolated a Windows extension linkage failure in #49, Thomas Munro suggested PGDLLIMPORT in #50, and Fabien incorporated the fix in #51.
- Aleksander resumed review in November, found unchecked strong-seeding failures, and supplied corrections in #52, considering the patch ready for a committer if CI passed.
- Tom's final review requested configure cleanup, clearer function names, explicit output ranges and nonnegative signed variants in #53 and #56; Fabien incorporated these changes in the final attachment #57.
- Tom committed #57 as 3804539e48 with moderate edits, including consistent upper-bit extraction, strong-seeding refactoring to avoid unnecessary OpenSSL linkage, additional unbiased range conversions and local state-handling fixes, and announced the push in #58.
- Fabien acknowledged the improvements and landing in the final message #59; the replacement was committed, while the SQL bounded-random function and broader pgbench bound support suggested in #36 remained possible follow-on work.