model-writtenrun 7337 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Heikki Linnakangas proposed moving WAL recovery into xlogrecovery.c while retaining startup orchestration and WAL-buffer management in xlog.c, explicitly requesting scrutiny of startup ordering changes in #1.
- Andres Freund requested smaller incremental patches, suggested grouping recovery variables into structs, and asked for per-record replay extraction in #2; Heikki retained the broader term “recovery” and supplied a seven-patch series in #3.
- After the July rebase in #5, Andres endorsed the preliminary cleanups in #6, and Heikki confirmed their landing in #7: signal-file opening, restoredFromArchive removal, and recovery-stop-reason extraction landed unchanged as e9f5a0681c, 6b16532811, and 4fe8dcdff3, while the global-variable relocation landed with wording edits as 317632f307.
- Responding to Andres's structural concerns, Heikki resent the three remaining patches in #8, keeping timeline initialization in XLogInitNewTimeline, naming cleanup ShutdownWalRecovery, and returning end-of-recovery information in a struct.
- Alvaro Herrera reported an assertion-enabled compilation failure in #9, and Heikki corrected the stale lastPageBeginPtr reference in #10.
- Following the September rebase in #11, Kyotaro Horiguchi reviewed behavioral changes, unnecessary includes, naming, and recovery-state ownership in #12, while Robert Haas analyzed startup reorderings and challenged control-file update timing and archive-recovery assumptions in #14.
- Heikki incorporated naming and include cleanup and added overwrite-contrecord refactoring and a separate WAL-position correction in #16; he defended preparing control-file state before subsystem initialization while delaying its disk update, and explained the division of minimum-recovery-point responsibilities in #17.
- The next rebase, #18, accommodated Robert's upstream removal of ReadRecPtr and EndRecPtr and omitted the now-unnecessary standalone WAL-position correction.
- Robert questioned overwrite-contrecord locking, possible flushing, and parameter shadowing in #19; Heikki responded in #20 by setting the page flag before record insertion, acquiring the insertion lock, adding position checks, and renaming the parameter.
- Heikki also added recovery-specific XLOG redo handling in #20 to eliminate the HandleBackupEndRecord callback, reorganized functions, and improved names and comments, while leaving a possible new resource manager for future work.
- Self-review exposed confusion between the timeline in a WAL filename and the timeline of its last record, so #21 corrected that distinction, added a regression test and formatting preparation, and folded the redo-handling and per-record extraction follow-ups into the main split.
- Michael Paquier identified an independently submitted overlapping test in #22; the discussion in thread #45144 selected Heikki's alternative from #21, which landed with a small test-harness adjustment as 50e5bc582a, whose message also acknowledged Amul Sul's separate test.
- Heikki reported the test landing but delayed the remaining changes while investigating a macOS CI failure in 027_stream_regress.pl in #23.
- The overwrite-contrecord prerequisite and StartupXLOG reordering from #21 subsequently landed unchanged as b3a5d01c05 and be1c00ab13.
- The main split from #21 landed as 70e81861fa with additional backup-state resets, a missing include, and comment cleanup; Heikki confirmed that the CI problem was fixed and the remaining work pushed in #24, closing the thread without an outstanding patch submission.