model-writtenrun 6279 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Michael Paquier proposed simplifying pgbench's numeric conversion helpers and aligning command-line error logging in pgbench and pg_verifybackup with other tools #1.
- Fabien Coelho opposed removing the helpers' optional diagnostics because additional callers could use them, and defended fatal logging for errors that terminate the program #2; he later cited documentation allowing programs to choose that distinction #7.
- Alvaro Herrera observed that pg_log_fatal() does not terminate execution and identified missing exit handling in pg_verifybackup #3; Michael acknowledged the bug and began checking for similar omissions #4.
- Michael invited a separate pgbench float-option parsing patch #8, while Daniel Gustafsson argued that logging should remain separate from termination and suggested an explicit exit function accepting a message if needed #9.
- Michael submitted a separate patch adding failure handling in pg_archivecleanup, pg_basebackup, pg_recvlogical, pg_verifybackup and pgbench, proposing backpatching only the pg_verifybackup fix #10.
- Fabien supported the pgbench fix and tentatively endorsed the remaining exits #11; Robert Haas considered all fixes reasonable, noting that pg_basebackup could continue after chmod() failure but that exiting could be preferable #12.
- The pg_verifybackup hunk landed unchanged as 2ad98fdf53 with backpatching through PostgreSQL 13, and the remaining hunks landed unchanged for the development branch as 856de3b39c, both split from #10.
- Michael closed the thread by confirming the changes and explaining his preference for handling permission failures consistently with tools such as initdb #13; the missing-error-handling patch was fully committed, while the original parsing and logging cleanup in #1 remained uncommitted in this thread.