model-writtenrun 6280 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Smith proposed replacing 'up2date' with 'up-to-date' in seven JIT and logical replication comments, arguing that leetspeak was inappropriate for code comments #1.
- Michael Paquier agreed that the replacement was clearer and committed the patch as 7b7fbe1e8b, adding capitalization and comment reflow; his announcement noted pgindent formatting concerns #2.
- After thanking Michael, Peter Smith disputed the commit message's attribution of most occurrences to recent work, saying the wording dated to the file's introduction eight years earlier #3.
- Andrew Dunstan questioned the hyphens, Geoff Winkless explained the distinction between attributive and predicate usage, and Andrew acknowledged the dictionary evidence #4 #5 #6.
- Gavin Flower favored consistent hyphenation for readability and searching, while Michael Paquier acknowledged that the JIT comment's usage was debatable; Geoff Winkless suggested 'current', which Gavin considered potentially ambiguous #7 #8 #9 #10.
- Andrey Borodin questioned the benefit of the wording change and suggested consolidating the six repeated logical replication comments into a documented helper; Peter Geoghegan agreed with the broader concern about unnecessary correction of old comments #11 #12.
- David G. Johnston defended this change as correcting a project style violation comparable to a typo, while Andres Freund emphasized the distraction and review cost of less clear-cut comment edits #13 #14.
- Andrew Dunstan closed by supporting fixes for errors, ambiguities and typos while opposing purely stylistic edits and accepting more informality in code comments; the patch remained committed, with no follow-up patch or revert shown and the broader style disagreement unresolved #15.