model-writtenrun 5896 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Thomas Munro opened the thread after AIO experiments exposed Windows basebackup failures on pending-deletion files, observing that stat() returned access errors before reaching its intended deletion checks #1.
- Thomas found that the older approach also failed and considered forcing backends to close file handles, while Tom Lane argued that opening a deleted file should return ENOENT and that recreating its name was a separate problem #2 #5.
- Kyotaro Horiguchi suggested renaming files before unlinking; Thomas tested that successfully but worried about special handling throughout the code, and submitted it alongside a smaller experiment retrieving NT status after Win32 operations #8 #9.
- Andres Freund questioned whether RtlGetLastNtStatus() reliably preserved the filesystem error and suggested a handle-returning open wrapper to avoid descriptor limits; Thomas incorporated that wrapper and also offered a direct NtCreateFile() alternative, reporting successful CI tests for both #10 #14.
- Alexander Lakhin verified the NT-status patch with his concurrency demonstrations and confirmed that he tested the version in #14 on master #16 #18.
- After discussion with Andres, Thomas abandoned direct NtCreateFile() calls because they depended on more unstable interfaces, added a non-interruptible sleep fallback before signal initialization, and resolved header conflicts in #19; broader POSIX deletion semantics remained complementary work elsewhere.
- Thomas classified the defect as longstanding and proposed an initial master-only landing; Juan José SantamarÃa Flecha questioned returning EEXIST for creation attempts, then accepted Thomas's explanation that it better emulated POSIX collision handling #20 #21 #22 #23.
- Daniel Gustafsson reported a Windows compilation failure and later returned the stalled patch with feedback; Thomas traced the problem to WIN32_LEAN_AND_MEAN and revived it with a rebase and the missing <winternl.h> include #24 #25 #26 #27.
- Thomas then confined the NT headers to the two translation units that needed them, verified MinGW cross-compilation, and posted the version intended for commit #28.
- Thomas committed #28 with only declaration cleanup and commit-message edits as e2f0f8ed25, then confirmed completion and buildfarm monitoring in #29; the thread ended with the fix landed on master and backpatching deferred.