model-writtenrun 6047 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed adding vendor and ABI-version integers to Pg_magic_struct so PostgreSQL forks could reject incompatible extensions instead of allowing potentially unsafe loading #1.
- Tom Lane questioned identifier allocation and the need for upstream support #3; Andres Freund argued that upstream support would produce clearer errors and encourage forks to identify incompatibilities, persuading Tom on the error-reporting benefit #4 #5.
- Tom Lane proposed a readable string instead of integers #5; Chapman Flack suggested a tag URI convention to avoid collisions #6, but Tom preferred user-readable product names over formal uniqueness rules #7, and Peter agreed that a single string was sufficient #8.
- Peter posted the sole patchset, adding a 32-byte abi_extra field, a compile-time length assertion, an FMGR_ABI_EXTRA setting defaulting to PostgreSQL, and an error identifying both server and library ABI strings #9.
- Robert Haas endorsed the patch as cleaner than Advanced Server's existing compile-time-constant workaround and asked about similar protection for incompatible on-disk formats #10.
- Michael Paquier supported the string approach and noted its potential value for Greenplum #11; Peter explained that catalog versioning already addressed the control-file concern #12, while Tom pointed to existing storage compatibility fields and treated further storage checks as separate from extension ABI checks #13.
- Peter committed #9 unchanged as d6d1dfcc99 and confirmed the landing in the final message #14, leaving no submitted patch outstanding.