model-writtenrun 7246 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
Oct - Nov 2021 · 8 entries
- Andres Freund proposed Meson in #1 to improve dependency tracking and incremental builds, replace the separate Windows project generator, and provide parallel test reporting across Linux, FreeBSD, macOS and Windows.
- Peter Eisentraut, Robert Haas and Tom Lane questioned whether Meson would constrain PostgreSQL's compiler and library choices in #3, #4 and #8; Andres demonstrated macOS GCC support in #18, and Tom said HP-UX need not block adoption in #75.
- Daniel Gustafsson supplied an independent pg_regress TAP-output prototype in #28, which Andres later recommended pursuing separately with a format selector in #122.
- John Naylor's macOS testing exposed temporary-install library failures in #35, Tom demonstrated SIP stripping DYLD_LIBRARY_PATH in #61, and Andres implemented relative references for PostgreSQL binaries while retaining absolute library install names for external consumers in #71 and #72.
- John corrected Meson's Flex invocation flags in #76, which Andres incorporated in #81, while the separate-build-directory work exposed Unicode/unaccent VPATH failures addressed by #86 and tested in #87.
- The expanded series #88 added missing programs, modules, tests, documentation, architecture support and cross-builds, while leaving PGXS, NLS, ecpg and other integration work outstanding.
- Peter simplified accept argument probing in #89; Andres's review #90 moved the fallback typedef into port.h, and the corrected patch landed as ee3a1a5b63.
- Portability investigation continued with OpenBSD, NetBSD and AIX in #94, while Tom defended retaining coverage of non-mainstream compilers in #95.
Feb - Jun 2022 · 9 entries
- Andrew Dunstan retained Windows import-library generation for transform modules and replaced unavailable pexports with gendef in #103; Andres accepted the approach in #120, and it landed unchanged as ea09a75e1e.
- After several months of branch development, #125 removed landed Python 2 and base-CI prerequisites and added dependencies, options and BSD support, including Nazir Bilal Yavuz's broader CI coverage; Peter's review #127 exposed the zstd linkage omission fixed in #128.
- The LDAP prerequisites from #128 landed unchanged as ee56c3b216 and 45fb0de4dc, making unsupported platforms skip the tests and adding OpenBSD's packaged paths.
- Peter replaced the Windows-only DLSUFFIX approach with generated-header handling for every platform in #134, approved by Andres in #135 and committed with cosmetic edits as 23119d51a1.
- The Unicode prerequisite from #133 was split: c64fb698d0 kept the Makefile VPATH repairs while deferring the generator output-directory interface, as discussed in #132 and reported in #136.
- The participants agreed to land Meson alongside the existing build systems and migrate buildfarm coverage gradually, with Tom supporting that plan in #139.
- Peter's contributions from #141 through #166 brought installation/header parity, ecpg, NLS, missing configuration options, dtrace support and configuration-output corrections into the evolving implementation.
- Stale generated parser files left by in-tree make builds caused failures discussed in #181 and #184; the maintainer-clean investigation led to explicit checks against conflicting generated source-tree files.
- Peter completed snowball SQL generation in #196 and reviewed generator interfaces in #195 and #204; Andres integrated these contributions and provisional PGXS support in #201, then standardized output options and MSVC callers in #210.
Jul - Aug 2022 · 9 entries
- Peter approved removal of the unused LLVM_CONFIG make variable in #204, and that component of #201 landed unchanged as 7775c748db.
- After Peter's approval #214, the first prerequisite group from #210 landed unchanged apart from whitespace: shell-path quoting a91242b1bc, psql generation 7c3c2cb9ae, ecpg generation db0a272d12, snowball consolidation b3a0d8324c, lwlock output paths 4f20506fe0, errcode output files 2bf626b714, Unicode output directories c8a9246e09, node-generation output directories adba4b7471, and Peter's dtrace refactoring eb6569fd0e.
- Andres revised Nazir's expected-directory support in #220, removing ecpg file copying and unnecessary fallback searches; the version included in #225 landed as c855872074.
- The remaining series #225 added extension pkg-config support, Windows ecpg testing, broader BSD CI and symbol-export cleanup, while its independently reviewed LDAP-header cleanup landed as 4ab53b647a.
- John began a separate scanner-compilation series in #232; Andres's reviews #234 and #236 prompted private headers and separate GUC refactoring, while #242 replaced a cube scanner global with a parser parameter and retained compatibility with older Bison.
- Peter's macOS library naming correction from #239 landed unchanged as 161355ee6d, while his Solaris review in #247 supported 3fb0687d32, whose matching attachment was posted as #513987 in thread #40487.
- Peter requested separating PCH, relative rpaths and extension support in #239; #252 made those follow-up patches, added Samay Sharma's documentation and extracted shared Darwin sysroot detection.
- The MSVC float-warning fix and Darwin sysroot extraction from #252 passed Peter's review in #258 and landed unchanged as 483ac64761 and 05519126a0.
- John committed the scanner work from #242 in three pieces: unchanged preparatory refactoring 1b188ea792, the relocated private header 80e8450a74, and the combined scanner conversions with small include cleanups dac048f71e, as explained in #274.
Sep 2022 · 14 entries
- Build profiling in #263 identified catalog generation as a bottleneck; John's whole-file parsing patch #278 landed with additional error handling as 69eb643b25, followed by b2e6e76823 implementing Alvaro Herrera's separate-perltidy suggestion #286.
- Andres and Peter proposed keeping parser-only headers private in #276 and #287; John's #295 implemented that relocation unchanged in ecaf7c5df5.
- The Perl minimum was raised to 5.14 after Tom arranged actual 5.14.0 buildfarm coverage in #300, enabling John's reviewed #301 to land as 4c1532763a.
- Peter's single-validation documentation patch #285 became ab393528fa with intermediate-file retention and related target fixes, while Samay reorganized installation documentation in #292 following Peter's review.
- Andres traced intermittent Windows ecpg-build failures to Python process exits under inherited error-mode flags in #294; the CI wrapper from #307 landed without its debugging print as 661ee7bfc6.
- The cleanup components of #307 landed unchanged as 8d513a6b71 removing obsolete DLLTOOL/DLLWRAP variables and 43fcaa345d replacing inappropriate postgres.h includes in portable I/O files.
- Peter's approval #317 cleared the remaining prerequisites from #307: gendef interfaces 70df2df1cc, removal of hardcoded TAP paths bb54bf2290, separate test log/data directories c47885bd8b, and PG_TEST_EXTRA checks c3382a3c3c, the last tightened to match whole option names.
- The final core submission #322 stopped building expanded documentation by default and repaired a generated dependency; e6927270cd landed with additional cross-build and target cleanups, deliberately leaving Windows resources, PGXS, LLVM bitcode and installation documentation for follow-up work.
- After the core landing, #342 resent the pending features, and #347 added running-server tests while avoiding parallel execution of the main regression and isolation suites against other tests.
- Peter's Windows resource-version review #353 led to the unchanged date-removal component of #347 landing as 31d2c4716e.
- Wang's report #350 showed that user CFLAGS were applied but omitted from pg_config, and reports by Nathan Bossart #335 and Peter Geoghegan #358 exposed installed-library lookup failures; the fixes in #361 landed unchanged as 1330dcdec0 and a1860071b3, using absolute rpaths while relative rpaths remained separate work.
- Thomas Munro reviewed the Windows macro prerequisites in #362, leading to the unchanged NTSTATUS component of #361 landing as b8d8a4593a.
- Andres split outstanding work into follow-up subtrees and discussions in #368 and #374, then closed the original commitfest entry in #377; this was an incremental landing, with PGXS, extension metadata, relative rpaths and other remaining features tracked separately.
- Peter Geoghegan's testing of the running-server setup in #358 informed later suite-selection refinements; Andres's isolated update #388 added documentation and FreeBSD CI coverage and landed unchanged as 3f0e786ccb.
Oct - Dec 2022 · 3 entries
- Andres revised XML dependency tracking and separate static/shared library construction in #374; Peter approved the group in #376, and its XML wrapper and ecpg components landed unchanged as 29668e3186 and a1261cd16f.
- Justin caught PCH activation misplaced in its prerequisite in #369; the FD_SETSIZE work from #361 was subsequently submitted as #517438 in thread #46726 and landed with light edits as 4289263cf2, while PCH landed as e5555657ba, initially disabled by default because platform support remained uneven.
- Later discussion still concerned recording Meson options in pg_config in #378 and #383, collecting failed-test logs in #385 and #386, and obtaining buildfarm support before retiring the MSVC scripts in #387.
Apr 2023 · 1 entry
- The thread ended with a profiling-support question in #390 answered in #391, followed by Andres's correction in #392 that the earlier Windows failure investigation meant SEM_NOGPFAULTERRORBOX; the core build system and the listed fixes had landed, while wider migration work continued separately.