model-writtenrun 5853 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Geoghegan proposed sharing VACUUM VERBOSE and autovacuum instrumentation to eliminate inconsistent accounting and excessive detail; Justin Pryzby supported the idea, and Peter clarified that an initial message would preserve table-level progress reporting #1 #2 #3.
- The first patch shared autovacuum's detailed summary with VACUUM VERBOSE, retained an initial table announcement, demoted fine-grained messages to DEBUG2, and removed per-step resource accounting #5.
- Justin suggested simplifying the instrumentation guard and reporting additional page statistics; Peter accepted the simplification but deferred visibility statistics to other work and considered hint-bit counting substantially harder #6 #7.
- Andres Freund questioned lost debug information, separate heap/index resource costs, complicated conditions, and loss of useful truncation and worker information; Peter defended operation-wide summaries and table-level announcements, while leaving some reporting choices open #8 #9 #13 #14.
- Peter refreshed the patch after bitrot and simplified the instrumentation guard without changing its architecture #15.
- Greg Stark supported separating progress from metrics but questioned machine readability; Peter pointed to pg_stat_progress_vacuum, explained the index-scan summary, and declined to promise a stable output format while the instrumentation was still evolving #16 #18.
- Masahiko Sawada found an uninitialized index-AM logging level and questioned a removed error-context comment; Peter fixed the logging level in the next rebased patch and explained why he considered the comment unnecessary #17 #19.
- Peter committed 49c9d9fcfa from #19 with moderate edits, retaining INFO messages for truncation and parallel-worker launches, completing logging cleanup, and documenting I/O timing; his final announcement confirmed the landing and thanked Masahiko and Andres, leaving no submitted patch outstanding #20.