model-writtenrun 5819 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Tim McNamara reported that running make in an unconfigured Git checkout referred newcomers to a missing INSTALL file and proposed adding an online installation documentation link #1.
- Daniel Gustafsson supplied a patch selecting INSTALL when available and README.git otherwise #2; Magnus Hagander requested a positive existence test and the website link, and Daniel incorporated both into the revision #3 #5.
- Peter Eisentraut requested indentation and quoting fixes and argued that the devel URL would become inappropriate after release, while Tom Lane endorsed the revised patch #6 #7.
- Daniel committed the revised patch with the indentation and quoting fixes as c330b75d9c, retaining the URL because he judged the discussion to favor it #8; Tom subsequently supported the devel link because the message primarily targets developers #9.
- Samay Sharma then reported the same missing-INSTALL confusion in README #10; Josef Šimánek proposed renaming the README files, but Tom opposed giving same-named files different contents in Git and tarballs, and Josef's alternative of merging the README files gained Tom's support #11 #12 #13 #14.
- Robert Haas proposed removing INSTALL altogether because online documentation should suffice and the absent file repeatedly confused newcomers #15 #17; Tom requested a README consolidation patch but defended INSTALL as useful version-matched documentation for tarball users #16 #18.
- Andres Freund proposed checking generated INSTALL into Git to retain terminal-readable instructions #19; Tom raised documentation-toolchain requirements and noisy generated diffs, while Andres described the smaller dependency set needed to generate INSTALL and acknowledged uncertainty about output stability #20 #21.
- Discussion turned to automated regeneration: Magnus Hagander opposed server hooks creating commits and suggested a job generating patches, Andres considered automated commits or validation viable, and Tom rejected tree-changing hooks in favor of simply unifying the README files #22 #23 #24.
- Magnus revived the discussion in March, explaining the operational problems with automated server-side commits and favoring removal of INSTALL #25; Tom accepted that flat-text instructions might be unnecessary but questioned how a replacement URL would select documentation matching the source version #26.
- Magnus proposed either a generic documentation link or updating version-specific links during branching #27; Tom preferred asking readers to select their version without additional automation, and Robert agreed that this should suffice #28 #29.
- After Magnus revisited major-version links, Tom favored linking only to the documentation index and directing readers to the appropriate installation chapters #30 #31; the Makefile fix had landed, but README consolidation and INSTALL's future remained discussion-only, with no further attached patch or resolution in this thread.