model-writtenrun 7338 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Robert Haas reported that fairywren turned a server backup target into the invalid target “server;C” #1, and Tom Lane and Thomas Munro identified argument-path conversion before pg_basebackup parsed the option as the likely cause #2 #3.
- Tom suggested separating the target type from its path and questioned the compact checkpoint-option syntax #2 #6, while Robert defended the existing conventions and Andres Freund explained that the conversion problem arose when MSYS launched native binaries #4 #8 #9; neither syntax was changed by this thread's commits.
- Andrew Dunstan initially suggested excluding the server argument from MSYS conversion #5, but that failed; following Thomas's suggestion to use Windows-form paths #12, Andrew posted a tested patch that consistently distinguished native-program paths from Perl filesystem paths throughout the basebackup test #14.
- Robert and Tom questioned the maintenance burden and requested documentation #15 #16 #18, while Andrew defended MSYS as a useful build environment #17; Andres then proposed running TAP tests with native Perl to eliminate scattered conversion workarounds #19.
- Andres reported that the basebackup tests worked with UCRT Perl and an early return in perl2host, although IPC::Run installation and environment-path handling needed attention #21.
- Andrew reduced his broad patch #14 to the immediate server-target correction, announcing the minimal fix #23 and landing it as 4f0bcc7350; the other proposed path conversions were left out while the native-Perl approach was pursued.
- After Robert added further backup tests and warned of possible MSYS trouble #25, Andres reported successful native-Perl trials alongside test hangs and handed the remaining migration work to Andrew #27 #28.
- Andres supplied a native-Perl build and test recipe with an experimental patch that bypassed perl2host and disabled troublesome tests #29; the recipe also called for two prerequisite reverts and used out-of-tree builds to avoid Windows executable-search problems.
- Andrew subsequently reported that both mingw64 and UCRT toolchains worked and that the experimental patch was no longer necessary, proposing the prerequisite reverts, fairywren migration, and removal of perl2host #30; Andres favored UCRT and updating jacana to MSYS2 #31.
- By the final discussion, fairywren was running TAP tests with UCRT Perl, Andrew had refined the prove invocation and dependency recipe, and jacana's migration was progressing #32 #35 #36; Andres also relayed Thomas's untested executable-search environment-variable workaround for in-tree builds #34.
- The planned perl2host removal subsequently landed as 95d981338b, deleting the disabled routine and adjusting callers, with backpatching through PostgreSQL 10; its matching source is the later patchset #499846 in thread #45538, which supersedes the earlier attribution to this thread's discussion.