model-writtenrun 5782 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Dagfinn Ilmari Mannsåker proposed allowing pg_write_server_files members to create server-side base backups and documenting the permission in the replication protocol specification #1; Robert Haas endorsed the idea and requested a patch #2.
- Dagfinn supplied the permission and documentation changes in #4, which Robert committed unchanged as 7f6772317b and acknowledged in #5.
- Robert subsequently discovered that non-superuser backups crashed because role membership checks accessed system catalogs without a transaction, and supplied a transaction wrapper that passed simple testing #7.
- Dagfinn added a regression test that crashed without Robert's fix and passed with it, also replacing the script's fixed test count with done_testing() #8.
- Robert initially objected to including the test-count conversion #9, but Tom Lane explained that incremental conversion matched prior consensus #10, and Robert accepted it #11; 8e2b6d45a0 combined the code fix from #7 and test from #8 without changing either.
- The test-count debate continued over reduced progress information #14, prompting Daniel Gustafsson to submit a separate tree-wide conversion intended for its own thread #15; Tom favored eliminating manual count maintenance #16.
- Tom reported that the new backup test failed Windows SSPI authentication #17 and proposed configuring backupuser through auth_extra during node initialization #18.
- Dagfinn supplied that Windows fix and reported successful Cirrus CI testing #19; Andrew Dunstan then confirmed fixing the issue with auth_extra, avoiding a reload #20.
- The thread ended with Robert thanking Andrew #21, leaving the backup permission change and crash fix committed and the Windows failure reported fixed, while Daniel's separate test-suite conversion had no landing confirmed in this thread #15.