model-writtenrun 5616 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Gunnar "Nick" Bluth proposed --config-file so pg_rewind could retrieve restore_command on Debian/Ubuntu installations with configuration outside the data directory, and initially requested backporting the feature #1.
- Jacob Champion verified that postgres accepts either dashes or underscores in long-option names #2, while Alexander Kukushkin preferred an explicit configuration-file path over an approach requiring data_directory in postgresql.conf and requested clearer documentation #4.
- After Daniel Gustafsson pointed to an alternative that supplied restore_command directly #6, Gunnar briefly offered to withdraw #7, but Daniel favored this proposal because duplicating configuration on the command line could let settings diverge #8.
- Gunnar continued with documentation improvements and an archive_cli TAP mode in #9, responding to the test request from Aleksander Alekseev #3 and the documentation review from Alexander Kukushkin #4.
- Michael Paquier identified unsafe shell quoting #10, prompting Gunnar to use PQExpBuffer and appendShellString() in #13; further review removed an unnecessary Cluster.pm change and clarified the documentation in #15, while raising the need to support crash recovery too #14.
- Michael Paquier extracted the command-generation work into a33e17f210 from #15, adding buffer cleanup and applying the same quoting approach to ensureCleanShutdown(); he confirmed the separate landing and declined a low-value executable-lookup refactor in #16, and the commit explicitly avoided backpatching because no existing failure had been reported.
- Gunnar submitted the remaining feature with configuration-file support for ensureCleanShutdown() in #17, then incorporated Michael Banck's wording, option-ordering, and comment improvements from #18 into #19.
- Michael Banck reported successful builds and TAP tests, then demonstrated that a crashed Patroni node could rewind successfully instead of requiring a fresh bootstrap, attaching a separate Patroni integration patch and marking the PostgreSQL change ready for a committer #20.
- Greg Stark reposted both unchanged patches to repair cfbot tracking #21, after which Michael Paquier recommended equivalent -c config_file= syntax and replacing the redundant archive_cli mode with coverage in existing tests #22.
- Michael Paquier supplied the revised patch with clearer documentation of restore-command lookup and crash recovery, plus simpler tests covering existing local, remote, and archive modes #23; Gunnar approved it #24.
- Michael Paquier committed #23 as 0d5c387573, changing only the help placeholder from FILE to FILENAME beyond rebasing, and confirmed the landing in #25.
- The thread ended with both PostgreSQL changes landed and Gunnar planning another update to the separate Patroni pull request; no further PostgreSQL revision remained pending #26.