model-writtenrun 4978 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Aleksander Alekseev proposed SLRU unit tests to make refactoring safer in #1, initially using a test module while moving initialization assertions into callers and simplifying the synchronization API.
- Daniel Gustafsson objected to the confusing boolean initialization result in #2, while Noah Misch, Pavel Borisov and Maxim Orlov favored regression-test placement and limited generalization in #3, #4 and #6; Aleksander responded in #7 by moving the test to regress.c, using a found output parameter and dropping the synchronization refactoring.
- Aleksander expanded coverage to reads, eviction, flushing, synchronization, scanning and deletion in #8, reporting 92.3% function coverage and 73.4% line coverage while leaving some error paths and the concurrency-dependent SimpleLruWaitIO() untested.
- Pavel considered the expanded, rebased patch #9 ready to push in #10, but suggested an initialization wrapper to avoid repeating assertions at every caller.
- After a seven-month gap, Michael Paquier argued in #11 that testing should preserve the established SimpleLruInit() contract and instead initialize a preloaded extension through shared-memory hooks.
- Michael separately committed the missing sync_handler comment from #9 as 5ca3645cb3, with revised wording, and announced its backpatch in #12.
- Aleksander adopted the preload design in #13, removing the core API changes and supplying a TAP-driven extension; Michael then recommended cheaper pg_regress tests with custom configuration and smaller SQL-callable functions in #14.
- Michael supplied the rewrite in #15, replacing the monolithic test and TAP harness with parameterized SQL wrappers and disabling installcheck because the module requires preloading; the suggested configurable SLRU directory was not included.
- Aleksander bounded the page-data copy and formatted Michael's rewrite in #16; Daniel and Pavel reviewed it favorably in #17 and #18, while Michael questioned Daniel's proposed direct pg_pwrite approach as duplicating SLRU internals in #19.
- Michael committed #16 with light comment, formatting and preload-error-reporting changes as 006b69fd91 and confirmed completion in #20, leaving both the comment fix and redesigned test module landed with no remaining patch submission awaiting review.