model-writtenrun 7229 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Thomas Munro opened the thread by identifying a SIGUSR1 call path into a potentially inconsistent buffer-refcount hash table in #1; Tom Lane confirmed the hazard in #2, and Andres Freund proposed limiting the handler to setting flags in #3.
- Andres identified a separate SIGALRM path that acquired locks in #4, while Thomas kept this series focused on SIGUSR1 and posted the first deferred-processing patch in #5.
- Andres's review in #6 prompted Thomas to replace communication through query-cancellation globals with direct recovery-conflict error reporting and a pending-reasons wrapper in #7; Thomas retained separate atomic flags rather than introducing bitmask operations.
- Reviews by Andres, Michael Paquier, and Robert Haas in #8, #9, and #10 led to #11, which separated iteration from individual conflict processing, retained established handler naming, consolidated FATAL reporting, and moved recovery processing after ordinary cancellation handling.
- Michael examined cancellation holdoffs in #12 and #14, while Thomas explained in #13 and #15 that recovery errors must respect protocol holdoffs independently of QueryCancelPending, which a signal can change at any time.
- Investigation of intermittent recovery tests broadened into repeated ERROR/FATAL delivery and excessive signaling in #17 and #18; Andres suggested interrupt protection during FATAL reporting and more careful signaling, beyond the attached SIGUSR1 fix.
- Thomas identified a blocker in #19: the regex engine checked cancellation flags directly, so moving conflict decisions into CHECK_FOR_INTERRUPTS() would leave expensive regex operations unresponsive; Tom suggested separating cancellation detection from throwing in #20.
- After several months, Noah Misch supplied a standalone reproducer in #21 showing that an irrelevant deadlock signal could overwrite the reason for a real lock conflict, and outlined alternatives for making regex cancellation compatible with deferred conflict checks.
- Thomas and Noah considered deferred errors, explicit cleanup, and palloc-backed regex storage in #22 and #23; Thomas then designed per-regex contexts reparented into a persistent cache and posted that prerequisite alongside the unchanged recovery fix in #25, dropping the immediate backpatch plan.
- Andres and Tom challenged the obsolete cancellation interface and discussed memory overhead in #27, #28, and #29; Thomas argued that memory contexts would not prevent a future two-phase interrupt API in #30, and Andres accepted prioritizing a development-branch fix in #31.
- Tom clarified that the existing cancellation callback was PostgreSQL-specific and could be redesigned in #33, leading Thomas to split memory management from interruption, replace REG_CANCEL with a configurable INTERRUPT macro, and add pg_trgm cleanup in #34.
- Tom accepted the regex direction but requested allocation-comment corrections, tsearch cleanup, and removal of obsolete caller-side interrupt checks in #36; Thomas incorporated those changes into the five-patch series in #37, leaving unrelated locale-cache allocations and a proposed README explanation outside that submission.
- Tom confirmed that the final regex changes passed his review in #39, and the memory-context component of #37 landed as bea3d7e383 with only comment wrapping changes.
- The complete tsearch and pg_trgm cleanup components of #37 landed separately as 4f51429dd7 and 6db75edb2e, with only formatting differences in the tsearch component.
- The regex interrupt-API component of #37 landed unchanged in code as db4f21e4a3, completing the four prerequisites while leaving the recovery-conflict fix pending.
- Thomas revived the remaining recovery patch in #40, adapting it to newly introduced logical-slot conflicts and incorporating Andres's explanation of why those conflicts need no ERROR-to-FATAL promotion.
- The last thread message, #41, replaced that submission after restoring an accidentally lost database-conflict case label; at that point the regex work had landed and the recovery fix was still awaiting commitment.
- The recovery fix subsequently landed as 0da096d78e from #41, with only a loop-variable declaration adjustment and commit-message edits, completing the submitted production changes; thread #48202 supplied testing rather than a replacement implementation, and the commit deferred backpatching because of complexity and the release schedule.