model-writtenrun 5392 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Shinya Kato proposed --bypassrls and --no-bypassrls for createuser in #1; Kyotaro Horiguchi identified missing VALID UNTIL, ROLE, and ADMIN support in #2, while Michael Paquier questioned demand and noted the feature freeze in #3.
- Shinya expanded the patch to cover those clauses in #6, but repurposing the existing --role option would silently change scripts, as Daniel Gustafsson warned in #7; #8 preserved --role for IN ROLE and introduced --membership for ROLE.
- Naming remained contentious: Robert Haas favored consistency with SQL in #10, Michael proposed paired replacement names in #14, and Robert rejected their ambiguity in #15; David G. Johnston supported --member in #16, Nathan Bossart agreed in #17, and Shinya adopted it in #18.
- Nathan requested tests in #19, and Shinya added them in #21; that response also declined Przemysław Sztoch's --comment request from #20 because COMMENT is outside CREATE ROLE.
- David treated comment support as a separate feature in #22, and Kyotaro reiterated in #25 that its implementation required separate discussion after Przemysław renewed the request in #24; no comment option was included.
- Nathan supplied a revised patch in #23 that corrected membership documentation, safely quoted password-expiry strings, refined help text, and added NOBYPASSRLS coverage; Shinya accepted those changes in #26.
- Michael accepted --member and requested repeated-option and quoted-name tests in #27; Shinya expanded the tests through #28 and #31, with Nathan identifying remaining gaps in #29 and #32.
- After Nathan reported Windows failures in #32, Kyotaro reproduced them and traced them to positional arguments preceding options in #33; Shinya corrected argument order and added quoted-name cases in #35.
- Kyotaro discussed more aggressive quoting examples but considered the existing escaping functions sufficient in #36, and Nathan accepted the revised tests and marked the patch ready for a committer in #37.
- In July, Michael first committed the unattached preparatory option-ordering cleanup as 50e4c280f0, explaining in #38 that accumulated options had become difficult to follow.
- Michael committed #35 as 08951a7c93, adapting it to the cleanup and extending tests with spaces in an ADMIN role name and password-expiry value, as described in #38.
- Noriyoshi Shinoda then supplied #39 to add the missing timestamp argument to --valid-until help; Nathan approved it with an indentation nit in #40, and Michael committed it with only whitespace adjustment as 4ca9985957.
- Michael's final confirmation in #41 closes the help-text fix, leaving all submitted functionality landed; comment support remained outside this patch, and analogous createdb cleanup was deferred in #38.