model-writtenrun 5014 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed typed allocation macros and example conversions in #1, aiming to keep allocated sizes and returned pointer types consistent while shortening common palloc and pg_malloc expressions.
- Bharath Rupireddy questioned existing casting practices in #2, and Tom Lane explained their limited safety in #3; Peter proposed gradual adoption followed by API backpatching in #4, which Tom supported in #5.
- Tom challenged the frontend/backend naming split and the _ptrtype and _obj names in #5, while David G. Johnston suggested _ref in #6; Peter retained both existing API families, accepted _object, and proposed dropping the confusing pointer-derived variants in #7.
- Peter's revised submission #9 renamed _obj to _object, removed _ptrtype, and split the API definitions from example conversions so the API could be backpatched independently.
- Robert Haas suggested frontend memory contexts in #10, but Tom argued that they needed a concrete use case and likely a separate implementation in #12; that broader work remained outside this series.
- Tom approved the revised series and urged API backpatching in #11; Peter announced its landing in #13, with 2016055a92 matching the API patch from #9 and 5015e1e1b5 adding seven mechanical conversions to its example patch.
- After Tom urged prompt backpatching in #14, Peter confirmed that the API backpatches were complete in #15.
- Peter opened a separate follow-up in #16 adding repalloc0 and repalloc0_array to combine allocation growth with zeroing the added space, replacing repeated backend repalloc-and-memset sequences.
- Tom supported the follow-up but requested old-size-before-new-size arguments and protection against reversed sizes in #17, then proposed checking the supplied old size against allocator metadata in #18.
- Peter asked how to obtain allocator sizes in #19, and Tom suggested a new allocator method in #20; Peter questioned the extra complexity and submitted #21 with reordered arguments and an assertion.
- In the final message #22, Tom accepted caller-maintained sizes, explained the danger of confusing requested and allocated sizes, and requested a runtime ERROR check instead of an assertion before marking the patch ready for a committer.
- The follow-up subsequently landed as b4b7ce8061, taking #21 with Tom's runtime check from #22; all submitted work had then landed, while broader frontend memory-context support and wholesale allocation-call conversion remained outside the completed patches.