model-writtenrun 2160 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
May - Oct 2022 · 3 entries
- Andrey Borodin reopened GiST and GIN verification in May 2022 with work originating from Grigory Kryachko and Heikki Linnakangas, adding GiST heapallindexed verification while leaving the corresponding GIN option unimplemented #1.
- Andres Freund requested separate patches for shared infrastructure, GiST, and GIN; Andrey adopted that split after improving vacuum and page-reuse tests #4 #2 #6.
- Early revisions repaired GIN downlink traversal and an ineffective regression test, and Andres supplied Meson integration after the build-system change #7 #9.
Nov 2022 - Apr 2023 · 7 entries
- José Villanova compiled the series, deliberately corrupted GiST and GIN indexes, and identified warning, include, and documentation issues; Andrey addressed these and added GiST progress reporting #11 #12 #13.
- Robert Haas argued that access methods need not expose identical amcheck options, and Andrey removed GIN's unimplemented heapallindexed argument after correcting an accidental wrong-branch submission #15 #16 #17 #19.
- Aleksander Alekseev requested negative corruption tests, while Peter Geoghegan challenged shared-helper boundaries, GIN concurrency assumptions, parent-check naming, and continuing after corruption #22 #23 #24.
- Peter supplied access-method-specific page-pointer checks and changed corruption warnings into errors; his exchange with Nikolay Samokhvalov established that continuing across different indexes belongs in pg_amcheck #29 #25 #26 #27.
- Andrey then shared relation-suitability checks, renamed gist_index_check() to reflect its weaker relation lock, documented traversal, and added GiST support to pg_amcheck #30 #31.
- Peter's GiST review prompted zero-initialized state, a separate per-page function, and additional defensive checks; his TOAST concerns also led Andrey to reproduce a false positive and introduce tuple normalization, with memory-management questions still open #33 #34 #36 #37.
- Alexander Lakhin found that pg_amcheck omitted GiST indexes without a schema filter; after a long pause, Andrey fixed discovery, rebased for the newer tree, and gated GiST calls on the installed amcheck version #39 #42 #43.
Jul - Aug 2024 · 2 entries
- Tomas Vondra reviewed the full series while testing parallel index builds, proposed shared-module cleanup, and reported a GIN debug assertion and false tuple-order reports on valid JSONB indexes #44 #47.
- Tomas also demonstrated a GiST memory leak, and Kirill Reshke supplied a small fix freeing the adjusted tuple; Kirill later took over revision work, incorporated Tomas's feedback, renamed verify_common and gin_index_check(), and retained both index implementations #49 #50 #51.
Oct - Dec 2024 · 2 entries
- Kirill's attempted maxoff correction proved wrong and was reversed; subsequent revisions fixed debug output on implicit posting keys and stopped checking the unstored rightmost entry-tree high key #55 #56 #57 #58.
- A further large-index test exposed another high-key problem, leading Kirill to supply an additional posting-tree right-bound fix on top of the full series #59.
Feb - Jun 2025 · 18 entries
- In February 2025 Tomas proposed landing GIN independently because he lacked confidence reviewing GiST, and Andrey supported separating the access methods so shared infrastructure would no longer block other work #60 #63.
- Mark Dilger extracted the GIN-only series, incorporated Kirill's fix, added JSONB and concurrent-index-build coverage, and wrote a stress test that exposed more false corruption reports #64 #65.
- Kirill reduced Mark's reproducer and traced the apparent bad ordering to comparisons across different indexed attributes; his next full series avoided those comparisons, although the stress test still stalled locally #67 #68 #69.
- Tomas prepared the final March submission by squashing fixes, polishing explanations and context names, and registering typedefs; Kirill approved it, and Tomas explicitly excluded the stress test from the planned landing #72 #73.
- The README grammar component of that final submission landed unchanged in substance as fb9dff7663, retaining Kirill's wording corrections and Mark's earlier review #72 #64.
- The shared locking, relation checks, security-context handling, and GUC cleanup landed as d70b17636d, taking the common-module component prepared in #72.
- The GIN feature landed as 14ffaece0f from #72, combining the earlier implementation and correctness fixes with light cleanup; the available preceding patches reproduce its checking logic.
- Mark's JSONB and concurrent-index-build test components landed separately as ca738bdc4c and 68f97aeadb, preserving the test changes carried into #72.
- Tomas immediately corrected comment indentation with ec4327d106 and announced that GIN had landed while GiST remained deferred, suggesting a new CommitFest entry for its eventual resubmission #74.
- Tom Lane reported that the new tests failed under OpenSSL FIPS mode because they used md5(); Tomas replaced it with sha256() in 49b82522f1 and confirmed the fix #75 #76.
- In May, Arseniy Mukhin wrote deliberate-corruption tests and discovered disabled parent checks, incomplete attribute-order comparisons, reversed split detection, skipped root and leaf checks, and posting-tree validation gaps; he supplied a new repair series #77.
- Tomas tested the repairs and attached an undo patch showing that the posting-tree changes were not covered; Arseniy then added a test that failed with that undo, improved endian portability, and removed the hardcoded block-size lookup #79 #81.
- Tomas cleaned up formatting and split the repairs into separately reviewable changes, while Arseniy improved their explanations and tests and added removal of the unused parentlsn field #82 #83 #85.
- Andrey reviewed the split fixes and raised questions about test stability and defensive page access; Arseniy adjusted the tests, and Tomas prepared the final series with clearer messages and a separate naming-and-scope cleanup #86 #87 #88.
- The final series' multicolumn regression test and unused-field removal landed as c89d6b889c and 8dd41c0bff, matching their respective components in #88.
- The entry-order repair and its cleanup were combined into 0b54b39233, whose files exactly match applying those two components from #88.
- The remaining parent-key and posting-tree repairs landed as cdd1a431f2 and 0cf205e122, preserving the corresponding code and tests from #88.
- At the last thread message Tomas intended to clear the PostgreSQL 18 open item but still had one commit to push; the supplied commit record shows the posting-tree fix landed afterward, while GiST support, the stress test, and proposed simplifications concerning deleted entry pages and gin_refind_parent() remained outside the committed work #92 0cf205e122 #74 #85 #86.