model-writtenrun 4828 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Smith opened the discussion by questioning apparently arbitrary statistics-view and function ordering in #1, then supplied two alphabetization patches in #2.
- After the patches were rebased, Tom Lane reviewed #5 and argued that alphabetical ordering should preserve meaningful relationships, such as tables before indexes and related view variants together; he also proposed sorting Progress Reporting by SQL command with Base Backup last in #6.
- Peter Smith supplied the separate progress-reporting patch in #7, while David G. Johnston recommended semantic groups for collected statistics, approved the LWLock and per-backend function corrections, and opposed disturbing the existing reset-function grouping in #8.
- Peter Smith combined the progress patch with three independently applicable table fixes in #9, abandoning the original blanket alphabetization approach.
- David G. Johnston broadened the proposal to separate HTML pages for individual views and hyperlinks in the summary tables in #10; Peter Smith added hyperlink cleanup and sect3-based table-of-contents suppression in #11, but had not yet achieved separate pages.
- Peter Eisentraut committed three complete components of #11: Progress Reporting as 6573643501, LWLock ordering as 9c558b94f0, and per-backend function ordering as b1d0158060, with only a blank-line difference in the progress component, and announced the landings in #12.
- David G. Johnston preferred separate pages over merely hiding table-of-contents entries and demonstrated a refentry-based solution in #13 and #14; after reposting the three remaining patches in #15, Peter Smith implemented that structural redesign in #17.
- Peter Eisentraut requested a reproducible ordering rule and separate stat and statio groups in #18; David G. Johnston explained his object-oriented alternative in #19 but accepted Eisentraut's ordering in #21.
- David G. Johnston reported successful compilation, missing hyperlinks, leftover description text, and a misplaced subscription-statistics entry in #22; Peter Smith addressed the review and adopted the explicit grouping scheme in #23.
- Peter Eisentraut committed the collected-view ordering component of #23 unchanged as 72e0ff2677, but rejected replacing explicit references with linked names because that weakened navigation cues, especially in PDF, in #24.
- Peter Smith removed the rejected hyperlink patch and reposted only the refentry conversion in #26; Peter Eisentraut questioned using man-page markup for selected views in #27, while Tom Lane raised bookmark and cross-version navigation breakage in #29.
- David G. Johnston defended separate HTML pages while remaining open to alternative markup in #28 and #30, and Peter Smith acknowledged uncertainty about other output formats and offered to drop the patch in #31.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed investigating a global sect2 chunking boundary instead of local semantic-markup changes in #32; Peter Smith dropped the remaining pagination work from this effort in #33, and Eisentraut marked the commitfest entry committed in #34.
- The thread ended with four ordering fixes landed and the pagination redesign left for separate work: Alvaro Herrera warned in #35 that changing global chunking would require a tested URL-transition mechanism for navigation between documentation versions.