model-writtenrun 5079 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Justin Pryzby opened the effort with #1, proposing fixes for shadowed variables newly introduced in PostgreSQL 15 and older easy cases so that useful shadow warnings would no longer be buried in existing noise.
- Michael Paquier argued for preserving separate local variables in #3, and Tom Lane warned about introducing bugs through scope changes in #6; Justin's expanded #4 consequently replaced several declaration removals with renames.
- David Rowley proposed tackling high-frequency warnings first and supplied the regress.c macro cleanup in #5, while Peter Smith advocated categorizing warnings and agreeing on fixes by category in #11.
- David narrowed the first landing to PostgreSQL 15 additions in #8, revised variable names and removed tablesync.c first flags using foreach_current_index(); Peter reviewed the slot handling in #9, and Justin confirmed reading the revised patch in #13.
- After tests convinced David that backpatching was sufficiently safe in #12, the PostgreSQL 15 cleanup landed unchanged as f01592f915, and the separate regress.c patch landed unchanged as 92fce4e1ed, as announced in #14.
- David next prioritized reducing outer-variable scopes in #14; Justin submitted broader work in #15, then narrowed it in #17 after David identified unrelated renames and declaration reuse in #16.
- The loop-scope work landed as 421892a192, retaining four patches from #4 and adding further cases from the unindexed revisions; #18 supplied a reverse-oriented record of omitted renaming and unnecessary C99 conversions.
- David categorized the remaining warnings by rescoping, renaming, reuse, refactoring and other cases in #20, then committed eight additional scope fixes as f959bf9a5b.
- Justin noted remaining ruleutils.c cases in #21, and David explained in #22 that those required variable reuse rather than the scope reduction used in the preceding batch.
- David supplied the gistbuildbuffers.c foreach_current_index() refactor in #23, reporting no measurable benchmark regression and abandoning a more complicated get_qual_for_range() refactor because its risk outweighed the cleanup benefit.
- Justin's variable-reuse submissions in #19 and #24 became 3e0fff2e68 after David removed some cases and added others, as described in #25; the separate GiST refactor landed unchanged as d389487525, confirmed in #26.
- Justin defended carefully chosen inner-variable renames and submitted the remaining work in #27; after a month-long gap, David returned with the expanded rename batch in #28, leaving only nested PG_TRY warnings and a pgbench time variable.
- Justin caught a missed datetime.c comparison operand in #29, and David corrected that rename before committing #28 as 2d0bbedda7, reporting a further review pass in #30.
- To preserve existing PG_TRY callers while supporting nesting, David proposed optional variable-name suffixes in #31; Tom endorsed the approach in #33, and it landed with only comment edits as 112f0225db.
- For pgbench, Alvaro Herrera proposed reusing the outer time variable in #32, but David initially chose the now2 rename discussed in #31 and endorsed by Tom in #33, committing it without an attached patchset as d8df67bb1a.
- Andres Freund's broader build exposed remaining warnings in contrib and optional GSSAPI and Python code in #35, prompting David's additional cleanup patch in #38.
- Andres tested and reviewed that cleanup in #39; David accepted removal of the duplicate PL/Python tdata declaration in #40, but retained separate GSSAPI return variables and the hstore macro local to avoid changing behavior or increasing multiple-evaluation hazards.
- Alvaro clarified pgbench's per-iteration time initialization in #41, and David acknowledged in #42 that reusing the outer variable would be safe, although this thread supplies no subsequent commit implementing that alternative.
- The final ten-file cleanup from #40 landed unchanged as cd4e8caaa0, allowing David to proceed with enabling the warning as announced in #43.
- Andres's build-system patch in #39 then landed unchanged as 0fe954c285, making -Wshadow=compatible-local a standard supported compilation flag, with the push confirmed in #44.
- Tom reported warnings from older Perl headers in #45; Andres favored retaining the flag, Alvaro suggested a PL/Perl-specific exemption, and Tom and David ultimately preferred waiting for actual complaints in #51 and #52.
- Michael Paquier found another warning under WRITE_READ_PARSE_PLAN_TREES and supplied #53; David approved it in #54, and the postgres.c rename landed unchanged as 4574eb9d38.
- By the thread's closing endorsement in #56, the identified cleanup batches and default warning flag had landed; the possible Perl exemption and a stronger -Wshadow=local setting discussed in #52 remained deferred.
- The supplied later candidate 853b35f35b selectively backpatched the elog.h portion of #31 in 2026 because other backpatched code required the optional PG_TRY argument on MINGW-64.