model-writtenrun 5020 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Bharath Rupireddy proposed consolidating backup code from xlog.c and xlogfuncs.c into xlogbackup.c/.h to reduce xlog.c's size, initially exposing WAL locks and shared-state accessors #1.
- Nathan Bossart requested a separately reviewable accessor prerequisite, while Michael Paquier preferred keeping SQL-specific checks in xlogfuncs.c; Bharath incorporated both suggestions in the next submission #2 #3 #4.
- Andres Freund objected to exposing low-level WAL insertion locks, and Nathan requested separating call-site changes from code movement; Bharath introduced helpers that encapsulated locking and restored the optional SQL-function move #7 #6 #8.
- Alvaro Herrera challenged the unlocked ControlFile pointer accessor, vague helper names, and public-header exposure; subsequent revisions copied control-file fields under lock and eventually placed internal declarations in xlog_internal.h #9 #10 #11 #15.
- Robert Haas cautioned that xlog_internal.h itself mixed frontend file-format definitions with backend internals, identifying a broader header-design problem beyond the proposed move #14.
- Alvaro proposed unifying backup cleanup paths, leading Bharath to add a prerequisite removing pg_backup_start_callback() and reusing do_pg_abort_backup() #13 #15.
- Alvaro's injected-error testing exposed that the replacement callback returned before undoing shared state during backup startup, potentially leaving forced page writes enabled; Michael suggested existing backup-termination test techniques, and Bharath revised the callback argument to bypass the early exit during startup #16 #17 #18.
- Alvaro committed only that prerequisite as df3737a651, changing the flag polarity and control flow, adding an assertion, and reporting successful CI and manual testing #19.
- Alvaro then supplied a separate cleanup eliminating forcePageWrites in favor of runningBackups; Bharath fixed omissions and comments, and Alvaro reported pushing the revised cleanup #20 #21 #22.
- Bharath resubmitted the remaining relocation patches after those cleanups; Alvaro requested clearer helper names and again opposed moving the SQL wrappers, so the next version retained those wrappers in xlogfuncs.c #24 #25 #26.
- Michael objected to the circular calls between xlog.c and xlogbackup.c introduced by the proposed split; Bharath defended the dependencies and submitted a rebased version without changing the approach #27 #28.
- After months without agreement, Commitfest manager Gregory Stark marked the remaining proposal Rejected and recommended a fresh discussion of goals, leaving the prerequisite cleanups landed but the main code relocation unaccepted #29.