model-writtenrun 7270 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Thomas Munro proposed standalone C TAP tests, Windows filesystem coverage, six bug fixes, and explicit POSIX unlink/rename semantics, incorporating Andres Freund's Meson infrastructure and work derived from Victor Spirin's proposal #1.
- The initial investigation distinguished sharing violations from pending deletions and found different behavior on Windows desktop and Server systems; Thomas favored explicit POSIX semantics but asked how ReFS and SMB behaved and whether those filesystems should remain supported #1.
- Testing by Andres, reported by Thomas, showed passing NTFS and ReFS tests but SMB junction-point failures and a readdir difference; Thomas added non-POSIX fallbacks, MinGW definitions, and safer test failure handling while leaving filesystem-support policy unresolved #2.
- Thomas landed the symlink errno fix unchanged as 359d601095 and the readlink length fix with one comment correction as 4650036f5a, both from #2.
- The broken-junction lstat fix, preservation of non-drive-absolute junction targets, and recursive-junction stat fix from #2 landed with their implementation unchanged but without tests as 387803d81d, f71007fbb3, and 4517358ee7.
- The pending-deletion unlink fix from #2 also landed without its tests as e109e43921, restoring retry behavior intended to address intermittent directory-not-empty failures in pg_upgrade testing.
- Thomas then submitted the four-patch remainder, rebasing the TAP infrastructure and POSIX-semantics proposal and consolidating all omitted bug-fix tests into the main filesystem test patch #3.
- In response to Ian Lawrence Barwick's question about superseding Victor's proposal #5, Thomas explained that Victor remained the primary author of the POSIX patch, while Thomas had removed obsolete version checks, added fallbacks, and supplied tests; the first two remaining patches were independently useful C testing infrastructure #6.
- After vignesh C reported that the Meson patch needed rebasing #7, Thomas withdrew the remaining series because enabling POSIX semantics on NTFS would leave ReFS and SMB behavior outside existing CI coverage, while retaining support for them prevented removing the old compatibility code #8.
- At the thread's end, the six bug fixes remained committed, while the C TAP framework, filesystem tests, and explicit POSIX-semantics change were withdrawn; Thomas left renewed work contingent on broader filesystem testing or a support-policy decision and preserved the tests for future reuse #8.