model-writtenrun 7252 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund extracted independently useful work from his asynchronous-I/O project to accelerate COPY: acquire and clean victim buffers outside the relation-extension lock, extend multiple blocks together, track concurrent buffer I/O through resource owners, and retain useful new pages in BulkInsertState #1.
- The initial benchmarks also exposed quadratic LWLock wait-list processing, and Bharath Rupireddy reviewed the proposed fix and requested named states and initialization updates #1 #2; the latest matching version was subsequently posted as #519019 in thread #46844, which receives attribution for a4adc31f69.
- After the LWLock fix landed, Andres returned in January with the remaining series, rebased and largely unchanged #5.
- David Rowley reviewed the initial helpers, while Heikki Linnakangas examined assertions, early extension-lock release, and victim-buffer separation; Heikki recommended removing dirty-write tracepoints rather than complicating the new allocation path to preserve them #6 #7 #8.
- Heikki questioned moving abort-time I/O cleanup into resource owners, and Andres explained that existing process-exit callbacks already depended on resource-owner cleanup; the series retained that design #15 #18.
- Heikki challenged the extension API's many arguments, and Alvaro Herrera suggested packaging common inputs; Andres chose flags plus a relation-identification structure and separate single-block, by-count, and to-size functions #16 #17 #28.
- Jim Nasby suggested extending larger relations more aggressively even without contention, but Andres kept precise heap_multi_insert demand as the baseline because speculative concurrent extensions could leave unnecessary space #20 #21.
- Discussion of recovery and VM/FSM callers favored buffered extension, and Andres rejected exposing the low-level extension sequence throughout callers; his filesystem experiments also demonstrated torn reads during extension #23 #26 #27 #31.
- The redesigned series added ExtendBufferedRelTo conversions for VM, FSM, and recovery, removed unnecessary VM/FSM initialization, and incorporated earlier review feedback; subsequent polishing extracted heap-extension logic into its own helper #33 #35.
- Melanie Plageman's detailed review and Kyotaro Horiguchi's portability review led to fallocate fallback corrections, simpler segment arithmetic, clearer pin-check naming, and buffer-index arithmetic fixes; the next series also avoided FSM updates while holding a buffer lock #36 #37 #42.
- The standalone local-buffer arithmetic correction landed unchanged from #42 as 558cf80387, followed by the unchanged early extension-lock release as 14f98e0af9.
- Heikki's tracepoint-removal proposal landed from #42 as 8a2b1b1477, with the obsolete probe declarations removed as well #8.
- John Naylor caught an error message that incorrectly assumed posix_fallocate had been used, and Andres changed it to name FileFallocate; the final submission omitted landed prerequisites, reordered the remaining work, and added hash and sequence callers #43 #44 #45 #46.
- The final submission's VM/FSM initialization removal and storage-extension helpers landed unchanged modulo whitespace as 3d6a98457d and 4d330a61bb #45.
- Pin-checking infrastructure and local-buffer pin helpers landed unchanged modulo whitespace from #45 as 819b69a81d and 794f259447.
- Victim-buffer separation landed from #45 with an added freelist return on mapping collisions as dad50f677c, while resource-owner tracking of multiple buffer I/Os landed unchanged as 12f3867f55.
- The central buffered-extension infrastructure landed from #45 as 31966b151e, adding guards for absent relation pointers and skipped extension locking beyond the posted patch.
- Andres split the final to-size conversion: VM/FSM changes landed as fcdda1e4b5, and the general ReadBuffer(P_NEW) caller conversions landed with comment cleanup as acab1b0914 #45 #47.
- The heap page-count work landed as 5279e9db8e, with bulk-state fields moved into the consuming heap-extension commit 00d1e02be2; that commit also adjusted unlock reporting and visibility-map recheck initialization relative to #45.
- The separate recovery conversion landed from #45 as 26158b852d after manual testing with disconnected standby segments, and Andres reported that the main series had been pushed #48.
- Some complicated callers intentionally retained ReadBuffer(P_NEW), and the development-only PrintBuffer helpers had disappeared from later submissions; further speculative extension heuristics and broader buffer-manager error-path testing remained future work #3 #35 #45 #48.
- After landing, Andres reported a separate copy-and-paste problem and discussed the difficulty of testing extension failures; Alexander Lakhin then supplied a reproducer for a recovery assertion after autovacuum truncated a relation #49 #50.
- Andres posted cleanup-lock support and recovery tests, Alexander confirmed the fix and identified the corresponding ReadBuffer_common assertion, and Andres extended the fix and added dropped-relation cases before committing 43a33ef54e #51 #52 #53.
- By the thread's end the main work and recovery follow-up had landed; the remaining exchange concerned Muhammad Malik reproducing the COPY benchmarks, with Andres explaining the input-generation step, COPY script, and throughput measurements #54 #56 #57.