model-writtenrun 4954 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Marina Polyakova opened the thread with a proposal to check ICU build support before encoding compatibility and missing locale options, improving misleading initdb and CREATE DATABASE errors while accepting later reporting of some failures #1.
- Marina added a separate Meson fix exporting with_icu to the scripts tests after encountering a CI failure, leaving the original validation patch unchanged #2.
- José Arthur Benetasso Villanova reported successful application, make check testing, and database use with pt_BR; his report addresses the validation behavior and does not establish review of the separate Meson fix #3.
- Peter Eisentraut committed the Meson attachment from #2 unchanged as 1d87037ac8 and announced that limited landing in #5.
- Peter opposed the broader early checks because they spread ICU-support conditionals and increase maintenance, describing builds without ICU as marginal #6; Marina proposed documenting that position or enabling ICU by default #8, and Peter clarified that this was his opinion rather than an established rule #9.
- Marina submitted a revised series retaining only the initdb encoding-before-locale adjustment and diagnostic tests, alongside new proposals to discourage builds without ICU and enable ICU by default #10.
- Peter questioned the revised initdb restructuring, its changed helper API, and the relationship of the createdb tests, and requested that dependency-default policy be addressed more generally in a separate thread #11.
- Gregory Stark suggested consistent separate checks for unavailable modules and parameter validity as a possible route forward #12, but no further patch appeared; Daniel Gustafsson ultimately marked the stalled work returned with feedback, leaving only the Meson fix landed #13.