model-writtenrun 4991 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed correcting ignored or misinterpreted pclose() results and extending wait_result_to_str() to report errno for -1, while marking uncertain psql callers for further consideration #1.
- Michael Paquier questioned consistency with callers already checking -1 and advised leaving the uncertain psql cases alone #2; Peter explained that the helper extension could eliminate those separate checks and questioned checking popen() without checking pclose() #4.
- Tom Lane questioned whether -1 could overlap a child status and whether FreeDesc()/ClosePipeStream() confused close and process-status semantics #3; Peter defended the established system()-style convention and explained that the wrappers passed the status through unchanged #5.
- Ankit Kumar Pandey reviewed the initial patch, reported clean application and passing regression tests, and found the implementation consistent with existing handling #6.
- Peter's revision removed the psql FIXME markers because broken-pipe errors already covered the practical concern, and withdrew pgbench's new rejection of nonzero user-command exit statuses because existing script expectations were uncertain, retaining the substantive pg_upgrade and other checks #7.
- Peter committed the revised patch with additional explanatory comments in wait_error.c as 2fe3bdbd69 and announced completion in #8; the uncertain psql checks and stricter pgbench exit-status handling remained outside the landed change.