model-writtenrun 7266 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Daniel Gustafsson proposed replacing the hardcoded SCRAM iteration count with a configuration setting defaulting to 15000 and permitting no fewer than 4096 iterations, initially leaving client-side integration for later work #1.
- Heikki Linnakangas requested a minimum of one for CPU-constrained clients, and Andres Freund opposed increasing the default because authentication overhead had driven users toward MD5; Daniel's benchmarks supported making the security-versus-connection-cost tradeoff configurable #2 #4 #5.
- Michael Paquier recommended making the setting user-settable and reporting it to libpq so password changes could honor it without sending plaintext passwords to the server #6.
- Discussion of future SCRAM algorithms led Daniel to try an algorithm-specific setting name, while restoring the default to 4096, allowing counts down to one, and implementing libpq propagation in the next patch #8 #9 #10.
- Jonathan S. Katz argued that users already control iteration counts through precomputed secrets and reviewed documentation and compatibility, while Michael requested consistent naming, a backend-only declaration, and the default count for mock authentication; Daniel incorporated those corrections #11 #12 #15.
- After a two-month gap, Daniel rebased the patch, made the setting user-settable, aligned internal names, and reduced test costs following Michael's review; Jonathan then said the patch looked good #16 #17 #18.
- Daniel settled on the generic name scram_iterations, reserving possible method-specific syntax for future standards, and then fixed a missed libpq parameter-name update identified by Michael #19 #20 #21.
- Michael's request to verify client-side password generation led to an interactive TAP test, and his concern about its five-second timer prompted Daniel to use the standard timeout and restart it for each operation #20 #24 #28 #29.
- Gregory Stark reported persistent CI failures, including missing IO::Pty errors, while Daniel wanted to wait for an interactive-psql test-framework refactor; Michael accepted deferring that test, and Daniel removed it while preserving server-side coverage #30 #31 #32 #33 #34.
- Michael's final review prompted explicit backend-variable initialization, removal of an unused import, and a test-session reset; Daniel posted the corrected patch, and the supplied thread ended with Michael's approval while the interactive test remained deferred #35 #36 #37.
- Daniel committed the final feature patch unchanged on March 27, retaining the default of 4096 and allowing user-configured counts from one upward #36 b577743000.
- The deferred interactive test from #29 was subsequently rewritten for the refactored psql test API with an IO::Pty guard and submitted as #532741 in thread #47344; Daniel committed that matching version on April 7 as bf5a894c55, completing client-side coverage through the other thread.