model-writtenrun 4449 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Thomas Munro proposed making cacheinfo entries clearer and less error-prone through designated initializers, omitted trailing zeros, and runtime key counting in #1, while leaving individual struct fields unnamed.
- Tom Lane supported removing trailing zeros but objected to runtime overhead and potentially hidden missing entries in #2; Thomas responded with compile-time KEY(...) argument counting and a missing-entry assertion in #3.
- CI exposed broken argument counting on MSVC, so Thomas bundled Victor Spirin's prerequisite fix with the unchanged syscache patch in #4; Peter Eisentraut endorsed the cleanup and suggested eventual generation from catalog definitions in #5.
- Nikita Malakhov asked about supporting five cache keys in #6, and Tom Lane explained that existing cases had required no more than four in #7; no expansion was included.
- Thomas committed the syscache component of #4 as cc15059634, omitting its introductory comment edit and the separate MSVC patch, then announced the push in #8.
- Thomas opened a separate follow-up in #9 to replace numbered syscache lookup interfaces with variadic macros and update callers throughout the tree.
- Peter warned in #10 that removing numbered interfaces would complicate extensions supporting multiple PostgreSQL versions; Thomas considered compatibility wrappers but withdrew the proposal in #11 because the readability benefit seemed too small.
- Alvaro Herrera suggested retaining the common one- and two-key compatibility interfaces indefinitely or for many years in #12, but the thread ends with the initialization cleanup committed and the lookup-interface proposal withdrawn.