model-writtenrun 3643 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Richard Guo opened the thread with three patches to allow postgres_fdw EPQ incremental sorting, avoid generating both full and incremental sorts for partially sorted cheapest paths, and initialize total_groups in grouping-path generation #1.
- David Rowley requested simpler tests and clearer comments, and questioned why the planner needed additional Gather Merge paths after generate_useful_gather_paths() #2.
- Etsuro Fujita explained that an EPQ recheck returns at most one tuple and needs the Sort node primarily to label ordering; Richard consequently withdrew the postgres_fdw patch #3 #4.
- Richard investigated whether the remaining path generation was redundant, and David supplied a parallel-safe volatile-function example and requested tests demonstrating why those paths were needed #5 #6.
- Richard's next submission added ORDER BY and GROUP BY regression tests, retained the ORDER BY consolidation, and removed grouping incremental-sort generation because grouped partial paths appeared either unordered or fully sorted #8.
- Shubham Khanna reviewed that version and reported that make check and make check-world passed #10 #11.
- After an applicability report, Richard restored grouping incremental-sort generation because group-key reordering now allowed partially sorted aggregate paths; he supplied a large-table example but omitted it from regression tests because he could not reduce its size sufficiently #12 #13.
- David questioned the restored logic and observed that the new tests also passed without the patch; Richard explained the reordered grouping example and clarified that the tests demonstrated the necessity of existing paths while the patch simplified their construction #14 #15.
- David combined both patches from #13 into 8ee9c25087, preserving their planner logic with light comment, formatting, and test-cleanup edits, and announced the commit as a partial-path generation simplification #16.
- Richard acknowledged the commit in the final message, leaving both planner changes landed and the postgres_fdw proposal withdrawn #17 #4.