model-writtenrun 3499 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Daniel Gustafsson proposed running all data-type compatibility checks through one connection per database in #1, reporting about a 15% reduction in check time for a cluster with 100 empty databases.
- Nathan Bossart questioned whether more checks could share connections and identified premature failure reporting in #3; Justin Pryzby supplied a broader callback-based framework in #4, while explaining that caching all database connections had hit connection and file-descriptor limits.
- Daniel retained the narrower data-type refactor in #5, adopting named initializers and reporting all data-type violations across databases before failing; he deferred broader consolidation because of complexity and release timing and declined to pursue the accompanying namespace-hash experiment because its benefits were limited.
- Nathan tested the revised reporting and found that PG_STATUS hid additional failure messages in #6, leading Daniel to use PG_REPORT and relocate applicability functions into version.c in #8.
- After a gap, Nathan supplied a rebase in #10, and Daniel removed redundant code and applied formatting in #11, explaining that splitting the large checker into smaller functions had made it harder to follow.
- Nathan's detailed review in #12 led to automatic check counting and clearer applicability-hook names in #13; he then caught a missing loop increment in #14, which Daniel fixed in #16 before Nathan judged the patch in decent shape in #17.
- Following another rebase in #18, Peter Eisentraut identified misaligned progress output and missing status-string translation in #19, both addressed in #20.
- Daniel adapted the patch to upstream additions for removed data types in #21, reporting check times of roughly 54 versus 126 milliseconds for an empty PostgreSQL 11 cluster and 33 versus 45 milliseconds for an empty development cluster.
- The patch was returned with feedback after remaining unappliable in #23, but Nathan urged getting it into PostgreSQL 17 in #24, and Daniel resumed with a rebase and corrected result-array initialization in #27.
- Peter's further review in #28 prompted translation of detailed reports and moving the private check struct into check.c in #29, and revived the idea of storing version applicability directly in the table.
- Daniel implemented version thresholds with a callback reserved for the special JSONB case in #30, then documented the fields and consolidated repeated report text in #31.
- Peter approved the final refreshed patch #32 in #33, and Daniel committed it unchanged as 347758b120, confirming completion in #34; the broader check framework and namespace-hash experiment remained outside the landed work.