model-writtenrun 3434 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Thomas Munro proposed an explicit pg_upgrade --copy-file-range option in #1, choosing user-controlled copying with errors on failure because kernel behavior and filesystem support could vary.
- Peter Eisentraut supported explicit mechanism selection and requested a preflight check in #2; Thomas implemented it in #3, and Peter approved that version with a temporary-filename correction in #4.
- After Thomas suggested extending the idea to pg_combinebackup in #6, Jakub Wartak supplied a shared-library implementation and pg_combinebackup support in #8, reporting that cloning reduced one large-backup combination from roughly fifty minutes to forty seconds.
- Peter recommended landing the ready pg_upgrade patch separately and removing unrelated formatting from Jakub's broader series in #9.
- Thomas committed the pg_upgrade implementation from #3 as d93627bcbe, correcting its EINTR handling and making small naming and testing-documentation changes, then announced the landing in #10.
- Tomas Vondra revived the remaining pg_combinebackup work with a rebase, prototype fixes and cleanup in #11; Jakub handed further development to him in #12 while offering testing and review.
- Tomas replaced the shared offload abstraction with local, separate copy-method functions in #13, deferring library unification because the wrappers were small and their callers had different policy and error-reporting needs.
- Robert Haas objected to rejecting checksum-requiring files in #14 and #16, leading Tomas to add per-file fallback to ordinary copying in #19.
- Thomas argued that copy_file_range could assemble files from multiple backups while preserving shared blocks even when checksum reads were necessary in #17; Tomas first added reconstruction support without that checksum extension in #21.
- Jakub's tests in #24 exposed an unbounded reconstruction copy loop, corruption after his experimental workaround, platform-support problems and a missing switch break; Tomas supplied fixes in #25, and Jakub confirmed successful reconstruction while finding a missing header dependency in #27.
- Robert's logging, documentation and dispatch reviews in #22 and #30 led to cleanup in #31, which also restored strategy-function dispatch and extended both whole-file and reconstructed-file CoW copying to operate alongside checksum reads.
- Thomas identified incremental-file header misalignment in #32 and requested batched calls and short-copy handling in #33, prompting broader performance work.
- Tomas's expanded series in #37 aligned incremental block data, experimented with explicit prefetching and batched copying, and reported large space savings from alignment and filesystem-dependent performance improvements.
- Thomas endorsed BLCKSZ alignment and discussed ZFS prefetch behavior in #38, while Jakub reported successful tests of the expanded series in #40.
- Tomas consolidated the work into six components in #41, fixed empty-file padding after Robert's off-list review, merged checksum support into the copy patches and simplified reconstruction with read/write helpers; Jakub tested this final series with assertions and multiple checksum settings in #42.
- The alignment component of #41 landed as 10e3226ba1, preserving small header-only incremental files while aligning stored block data.
- The whole-file copying component of #41 landed as f8ce4ed78c, retaining requested CoW methods during checksum calculation and correcting documentation and parameter ordering before commit.
- The reconstruction component of #41 landed as ac81101551, using copy_file_range for individual reconstructed blocks and separate reads for checksums, with the minor cleanup reported in #44.
- Tomas reported two buildfarm compile-time problems after landing and resubmitted the remaining prefetching and batching work in #44, but deferred it beyond PostgreSQL 17 because benchmarks showed regressions and unresolved tradeoffs.
- Further testing in #45 showed that default-sized ZFS records restored competitive performance, and Tomas concluded in #46 that explicit prefetching should remain uncommitted; the core copying and alignment work had landed, while batching and prefetching remained deferred.