model-writtenrun 7239 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Jeff Davis proposed retaining ICU as the build-time default while restoring libc as initdb's default before beta2, because C/C.UTF-8 handling and the broader initialization rules still lacked consensus #1.
- Jeff also proposed removing the unpopular conversion of ICU locale C to en-US-u-va-posix and preferred keeping invalid-locale validation at WARNING for one release, while accepting that returning to libc would make ERROR less risky #1.
- Tom Lane endorsed the proposed changes #2.
- Jeff submitted two patches, explaining that the libc-default revert also removed automatic ICU locale selection because it belonged to the same original change; the second patch removed special C/POSIX handling and adjusted tests for ICU-version-dependent behavior #3.
- Jonathan S. Katz raised no objections on behalf of the release management team, clarified its understanding of the ICU build default, and personally favored consulting packagers and retaining WARNING-level validation #4.
- After the final thread message, Jeff committed the first patch unchanged as 2535c74b1a; although rollback discussion also occurred in thread #47790, the matching attachment is #3, and the supplied evidence leaves the second patch's disposition and the validation-level decision unconfirmed.