model-writtenrun 7211 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Masahiko Sawada reported severe PostgreSQL 16 COPY regressions at low concurrency on XFS and traced them to alternating fallocate and write-based extension in #1; Jakub Wartak reproduced the filesystem behavior in #5 and #13, while Heikki Linnakangas saw no comparable effect on ext4 in #3.
- Andres Freund proposed remembering previous bulk-extension sizes in #10, then separated the single-client slowdown into per-row COPY DEFAULT allocation and slower integer parsing in #15; increasing COPY's buffering limit helped experimentally but was not presented as the solution.
- Masahiko supplied the allocation-once COPY DEFAULT fix in #16 and an independent initial-digit-check experiment in #17, but Dean Rasheed's benchmarks showed that only the allocation fix reliably helped on his machine in #18.
- David Rowley switched integer parsing to decimal-first dispatch in #19, and Dean simplified its dispatch condition in #20, but Andres still found inconsistent performance and highlighted digit-classification overhead in #22.
- David tested alternative overflow arithmetic and cheaper digit classification in #23; Andres then proposed a separate common-case decimal parser with fallback in #24, which David repaired and developed into two overflow-checking alternatives in #26.
- David committed Masahiko's COPY DEFAULT fix as b635ac03e8, changing only allocation placement, and explained the adjustment in #27.
- John Naylor's Intel benchmarks in #29 and Andres's wider, parsing-focused benchmark in #30 supported fixing integer parsing for PostgreSQL 16 and favored the unsigned-accumulator fast path.
- David extended the fast path to all integer widths and optimized the first digit in #32; Dean caught acceptance of sign-only input in #33, prompting the correction in #34, which Dean subsequently benchmarked and endorsed in #35.
- David committed the corrected parser as 3845577cb5, adding only documentation changes beyond #34, and reported the landing in #36.
- After the performance item was closed in #38, Masahiko demonstrated that the original concurrent COPY regression remained despite improved single-client performance in #39.
- Andres implemented remembered extension history in BulkInsertState in #40, and Masahiko confirmed substantial improvements across concurrency levels in #41.
- Andres polished comments without changing behavior in #42, and that patch landed unchanged as development-branch 82a4edabd2, with d37ab378b6 representing the same change on PostgreSQL 16 despite both appearing as candidates.
- Andres left further waiter-count optimizations and broader BulkInsertState use for later work in #42, and Alvaro Herrera closed the original performance issue after the extension fix landed in #43.
- Tom Lane traced a small-shared_buffers pg_visibility test failure to the more aggressive extension heuristic in #45; Andres explained the buffer-pin limit and discussed making the test tolerate trailing empty pages in #46.
- Tom then supplied a reproducer for partitioned COPY read failures in #47, and Andres diagnosed stale bulk-extension state being reused across partitions in #49.
- With no feedback favoring a larger redesign, Andres chose the minimal ReleaseBulkInsertStatePin() reset in #51, developed a compact regression test in #52, and submitted the fix plus a separate defensive assertion proposal in #53.
- The reset and regression test landed as 22655aa231, with only comment edits to the first patch of #53; the final thread message #54 confirms the push, while the separate assertion proposal remains unconfirmed and the pg_visibility test issue is unresolved within the supplied messages.
- The pg_visibility issue was subsequently resolved by 3a4837fc80, which adopts Heikki Linnakangas's smaller test table from #542636 in thread #48262; that thread's exact matching patch establishes its provenance and replaces the earlier attribution to this thread's discussion.