model-writtenrun 4187 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Daniel Gustafsson proposed including the pg_controldata cluster state in pg_upgrade shutdown errors to aid troubleshooting, attaching an untested initial patch in #1.
- Zhang Mingli supported the additional detail in #2.
- Tom Lane agreed with the proposal but pointed out that the state string's trailing newline would spoil the output, recommending stripping it and simplifying the comparison strings in #3.
- Daniel Gustafsson incorporated that feedback in #4, adding newline stripping and updating the comparisons; the thread ended with his intention to commit unless anyone objected.
- The revised patch from #4 landed unchanged in a3f695e645, completing the proposed improvement.