model-writtenrun 4120 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Nathan Bossart proposed per-step pg_upgrade timing in #1 to identify downtime bottlenecks and measure future performance improvements.
- Bharath Rupireddy recommended INSTR_TIME macros and simpler output in #2; Nathan adopted those suggestions and added both milliseconds and human-readable durations in #4.
- Bharath reported successful testing on a 22GB database in #5 and discovered an existing spacing defect where the longest status message ran directly into its completion indicator.
- Nathan initially addressed that defect by shortening and harmonizing data-type messages, using Bharath's preferred wording from #7, while adding translation markers to the timing strings in #8; he retained separate formatting code because sharing psql's implementation would complicate translation.
- Peter Eisentraut questioned the usefulness of default timing output and the loss of precision in shortened messages in #9 and #10; Daniel Gustafsson suggested opt-in debugging output in #11, Nathan accepted that possibility in #13, and Jacob Champion supported timing and progress visibility while favoring opt-in millisecond detail in #14.
- Peter suggested external timestamping in #15; after Bharath raised portability and elapsed-time concerns in #18, Peter pointed to ts -i in #19, and Nathan agreed built-in timing could be left aside absent further justification in #20.
- For the spacing defect, Peter proposed initdb-style output without aligned completion indicators in #16; despite Bharath's preference for a smaller wording fix in #17, Nathan supplied a working formatting rewrite in #22, with backpatch suitability still a concern in #21.
- After a gap, Peter recommended increasing MESSAGE_WIDTH to 62 for PostgreSQL 16 and deferring broader restructuring in #23; Nathan agreed in #24 and posted the one-line patch in #25.
- The final patch landed unchanged as 9625845532, with a backport to PostgreSQL 16, and Nathan confirmed completion in #26; the spacing defect was fixed, while built-in timing and the broader output redesign remained uncommitted in this thread.