model-writtenrun 4139 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Dave Cramer proposed replacing literal protocol characters with descriptive macros in a new protocol.h, removing redundant comments beside their uses #1.
- Alvaro Herrera requested common naming prefixes #2, while Tatsuo Ishii objected to using Describe-specific names for Close subcommands #5; Dave introduced shared subcommand names and corrected mistaken DataRow/Describe substitutions in #9.
- Alvaro then identified misleading authentication names, missed character substitutions and tracing comments needing updates #11, which Dave addressed in #12.
- Peter Smith suggested an enum for type checking and switch coverage #13, but Alvaro warned that omitting default cases would mishandle malformed protocol traffic #14, and the patch retained macros.
- Robert Haas and Tom Lane advocated names matching the protocol documentation and preserving its capitalization for searching #16 #17; Dave adopted PqMsg CamelCase names in #25.
- Peter Eisentraut clarified that the names should exactly match protocol.sgml, without invented Request/Response suffixes, and proposed the PqMsg_ prefix and pqcomm.h placement #28; Tom supported canonical names #30, and Alvaro supported the underscore #33.
- Nathan Bossart supplied a revised full patch implementing that feedback, retaining Dave's authorship credit and limiting scope to codes named in the documentation #34; it removed invented subcommand and progress-code names, distinguished the documented meanings of authentication 'p', and added assertions for shared tracing identifiers.
- Tatsuo requested a standalone header usable by middleware without pqcomm.h's dependencies #35 #37, and Alvaro supported that rationale #39; Nathan moved the message macros and authentication constants into libpq/protocol.h and added installation rules #41.
- Michael Paquier found the missing MSVC header installation and stale PQsendTypedCommand() comments, while pointing out additional unnamed protocol fields #42; Nathan fixed the installation and comments in #43 and explicitly deferred naming other fields to follow-up discussion.
- Robert approved the final version's readability #44, and Nathan committed #43 unchanged as f4b54e1ed9, crediting Dave and seven reviewers.
- Nathan's final message confirmed the commit #47, completing the submitted patch while leaving broader naming of undocumented fields outside this thread's landed scope.