model-writtenrun 7221 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Quan Zongliang proposed a separate fast loop for all-visible pages requiring no serializable conflict checks, avoiding tuple construction and other per-tuple work, with profiling results from a 30-million-row TPC-H orders table #1.
- John Naylor pointed to Andres Freund's earlier proposal, which specialized all execution paths without duplicating the loop, and requested reproducible timings; after Quan explained his EXPLAIN ANALYZE measurements, John warned about its overhead and recommended testing current master #2 #3 #4.
- Quan reported that optimized builds performed similarly with either approach and attributed this to the always-inline helper and constant arguments in Andres's patch; he also clarified that the first execution was excluded from the averages #5 #6.
- John concluded that Andres's broader specialization had no apparent downside in this workload and suggested withdrawing Quan's competing patch from the commitfest, which Quan accepted in the thread's final message #7 #8.
- Andres Freund subsequently committed the inline-helper implementation from the later patchset #559336 in thread #48166, with light declaration and comment edits and added credits; the commit cites both discussions and credits Quan's testing, while this thread's competing attachment remained withdrawn a97bbe1f1d.