model-writtenrun 4001 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Данил Столповских proposed ALTER TYPE DROP VALUE with catalog deletion, documentation, and tests in #1, but Vik Fearing identified surviving index high keys in #2 and Tom Lane identified existing stored values in #3 as unresolved correctness problems.
- Andrew Dunstan proposed retaining enum entries with a DISABLE flag in #4; Tom Lane explained in #5 that this could help prevent concurrent insertions during validation but would not eliminate values retained in non-leaf index pages.
- Vik Fearing submitted a separate grammar placeholder in #6 that rejects DROP VALUE and places comments about the unresolved problems where future implementers would find them, deliberately omitting user documentation.
- Tom Lane suggested removing “yet” from the placeholder error in #7, while Andrew Dunstan explored reindexing and replacing the enum type in #8, acknowledging timing difficulties and the cost of rewriting large tables.
- Vik Fearing advocated committing the explanatory patch in #9, and Dagfinn Ilmari Mannsåker endorsed it and the error wording change in #10.
- Tom Lane examined DISABLE further in #11, identifying difficulties querying disabled values and restoring backups; Vik Fearing accepted editorial changes to the explanatory patch in #12.
- Tom Lane committed #6 as af3ee8a086, adding metadata and index-persistence explanations and removing “yet”; he reported in #13 that he omitted the regression tests because they would add test cycles without helping implementers discover the comments.
- After the commit, Matthias van de Meent proposed domain-style validation and marking enum values deleted in #15; Tom Lane explained in #16 that domain validation leaves concurrency, temporary-table, and metadata gaps that could cause broken enum comparisons and indexes, leaving actual deletion and acceptable handling of orphaned values unresolved.