model-writtenrun 3819 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Richard Guo reported an assertion failure caused by self-join elimination modifying shared required_relids bitmapsets and proposed copying before substitution in replace_relid(), while also considering copying where clauses are constructed #1.
- Alexander Korotkov questioned the mixed copying behavior and suggested removing the assertion #2, but Andres Freund explained that bitmapset modification can free the shared allocation, making this a use-after-free risk #4; Alexander accepted that explanation #5.
- Andres Freund proposed forcing bitmapset reallocation to expose stale pointers, demonstrated that Richard's patch also needed copying in the deletion-only path, and identified callers passing the same bitmapset as both arguments #3.
- Alexander Korotkov introduced REALLOCATE_BITMAPSETS and NodeTag assertions, accompanied by broader copies in equivclass.c, initsplan.c and restrictinfo.c that made regression tests pass #7.
- Ashutosh Bapat requested separate assertion and reallocation patches, questioned the memory cost of broad copying, and suggested marking immutable bitmapsets as final to detect unintended modification #8.
- Richard Guo argued that sharing bitmapsets was valid if modifications copied first and extended replace_relid() to cover deletion #9; Alexander adopted that fix, dropped the broader optimizer copies, and split the instrumentation into a three-patch series #10.
- Ashutosh Bapat requested memory measurements #12, while Andres Freund questioned the maintenance safeguards for updating PlannerInfo during relation removal #13; Alexander promised a documenting comment, although no such patch appears in the supplied thread #14.
- Andrei Lepikhov approved the assertions and localized SJE fix but urged caution about reallocation and memory consumption #15, and Alexander Pyhalov confirmed a previous partitioned-join case that exhausted a test machine's memory #16.
- Ashutosh Bapat shared bitmapset memory analysis #17 and clarified that its improvements came from other changes reducing the number of containing objects #21, while Richard Guo pointed to separate work postponing path reparameterization #19.
- Alexander Korotkov measured the final series with Ashutosh's tests and found small overhead for nonpartitioned self-joins and no change for partitioned cases, where self-join elimination did not operate; he concluded that correctness justified the copies and identified partitioned self-join elimination as future work #22.
- Alexander Korotkov committed all three patches from #10: assertions as 71a3e8c43b, reallocation instrumentation as 7d58f2342b, and Richard's replace_relid() fix as e0477837ce, with only rebase context changes to the last patch; the thread ends with his confirmation that the series was pushed #25.