model-writtenrun 3467 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Nathan Bossart proposed compile-time AVX2 support in simd.h with promising large-workload benchmarks, initially awaiting compiler-detection support and buildfarm coverage #1.
- Tom Lane requested explanatory comments and questioned mutually exclusive SSE2 and AVX2 definitions; Nathan defended the vector abstraction and supplied an AVX2-enabled buildfarm animal, while John Naylor challenged the maintenance cost without an accessible build configuration #4 #5 #6 #8.
- Nathan proposed either a configuration option or documentation for existing compiler flags, and John favored considering future compatibility and Windows support; no final AVX2 availability mechanism was adopted in this thread #10 #12.
- John identified a potential regression because wider vectors enlarge the scalar tail, then proposed overlapping SIMD blocks; Ants Aasma explained why repeated comparisons preserve correctness, and John illustrated searching the first and last blocks of an array #11 #14 #18 #19.
- After a two-month gap, Nathan combined overlapping-tail processing, refreshed AVX2 support, and a microbenchmark; measurements showed broad benefits from overlap but AVX2 regressions on smaller arrays #20.
- Nathan added two-register tail processing to mitigate those regressions, removed the benchmark patch to satisfy CI, and reordered the series to demonstrate benefits without AVX2, including a scalar shortcut for small arrays #21 #23.
- John objected to extra loops, branches, and retry control flow, prompting Nathan to post a standalone alternative using a two-register helper and bounded tail checks #24 #26 #27.
- John warned that fixed-length microbenchmarks could hide branch-prediction costs, and Nathan subsequently removed the two-register path in favor of a shared four-register helper #28 #29 #30.
- John suggested a do-while loop and fewer tail checks, which Nathan implemented; extended measurements showed reduced incremental benefit from AVX2, while separate tests still favored four-register processing #31 #32 #34.
- Nathan narrowed the submitted series to the search optimization, fixed missing SIMD guards and assertion-loop index handling, and received John's favorable review with a comment correction #35 #36 #37.
- Nathan's final optimization also routed exactly one block through SIMD after measuring a substantial improvement for that case, and it landed unchanged as 7644a7340c from #39.
- Nathan marked the work committed while explicitly leaving AVX2 support for possible future reconsideration #40.
- Tom reported unused-label warnings on non-SIMD buildfarm machines, leading to 1f42337be5, which moved the label inside the SIMD conditional without an attached patch #41 #43.
- Nathan then proposed extracting scalar search into an inline helper after checking performance; Tom approved the cleanup while requesting an unsigned iterator and const-qualified array arguments, which Nathan incorporated #45 #46 #47.
- The cleanup landed unchanged as 7188a7806d from #47, and the final message confirms completion of that work, with AVX2 itself still deferred #48 #40.